Benjamin Ong's notes

Notes about Singapore public law, etc. for my students (and possibly others)

Various tips on writing research papers, answering essay questions, thinking about the law, etc.

Other blogs

I would like to recommend to you the blog of Dr Dimitrios Kyriazis: https://www.thelawprof.com/writing-legal-essays-1. There are several posts there about writing essays. They focus on essays about the law, but the advice there is really applicable to any sort of essay.

I would particularly recommend a blog post by Professor Mark Elliott, which a colleague kindly shared with me: https://www.thelawprof.com/writing-legal-essays/remember-to-argue-guest-post-by-professor-mark-elliott. I have always found Professor Elliott’s writing clear and smooth.

Consider this Instagram post by Juliette Han: https://www.instagram.com/p/Cxng-BkOjdA/

Miscellaneous points

Feel free to critique materials you come across, including the views of courts and academics (including me). You are free to explain not only that you take a certain view because X says so, but also that you agree with X’s view but not for the reasons that X refers to.

In general, it is good, not bad, to acknowledge potential flaws in or possible criticisms of one’s arguments. It would be better to confront such possible criticisms than to give the impression that one is trying to get away with letting them slip by unnoticed.

Consider categorising things. For example, when unpacking the assertion that there is “diversity” in the law, consider different types of diversity: a diverse range of legal doctrines? a diverse range of approaches to different sets of facts? 

Something may be principled even if the underlying principle is not expressly articulated.

Embracing a concept doesn’t translate directly to performing certain activities. Consider the idea of embracing the concept of human dignity. For some, that concept means abolishing the death penalty; for others, it means that the condemned person walks to the gallows instead of being dragged there; for others, it could mean encouraging the death penalty for those who have committed crimes against dignity; for yet others, it could mean retaining the death penalty, but varying the method of execution. (This point is my paraphrase of certain ideas which I was exposed to by a lecture by Professor Jeremy Waldron, in case you’re interested in reading more about human dignity.)

If you say that something should be abolished, does it need to be replaced with something else?

The law sets out minimum standards, not ideal standards to aspire to. For example, if you have never committed a serious crime, that is not something to boast about, any more than washing your hands is something to boast about. Acting unlawfully is not bad, but acting lawfully doesn’t make you good/excellent. (The phrase “hygiene factor” comes to mind.) So, if all that can be said in support of an idea is that it would not be unlawful, then perhaps we should think twice about whether it is such a great idea.

If you criticise something for being insufficiently detailed, consider whether it is (a) possible and (b) desirable to provide further detail.

Even if something is not binding on X, X can still choose to follow it.

It is possible to argue that, in order to do task A better, someone should also be made to do task B. 

Guiding the reader

It is difficult to prescribe a structure for any essay. Instead, I would like to offer this tip: Your reader should rarely, if ever, be left wondering ‘why is this person saying this?’ or ‘why is this point suddenly coming out of left field?’ or ‘what is this idea that this person keeps mentioning but hasn’t unpacked?’ To avoid this, you should not only sequence what you have to say in a logical manner — for example, if you need to provide background knowledge in order to set the stage before making a point, then do so — but also provide useful signposting. Phrases like “There are two arguments… First… Second… One might argue that… But this would miss the point…” or “It depends what one means by the right to life. If one means… But that would hardly be satisfactory because… Instead, the right to life, in its fuller sense, means…” would show how each statement leads to the next/follows from the previous one, and would thus help the reader to follow the argument.

Answering ‘yes/no’, ‘good/bad’, etc. questions

You need not answer what appears a yes/no question with a simple yes or no. ‘It depends’ can be a valid and useful answer. However, you don’t want to just say ‘it depends’ and leave it at that. Rather, explain: what is ‘it’ and what does it depend on? 

Your answer could be something like ‘if X means A, then yes; if X means Y, then probably no’; ‘yes in the short term; no in the long term; the right time to transition between the two is…’; ‘yes, provided that the following conditions are met’; ‘it doesn’t matter whether or not one does X; what is more important is Y’; etc. If the question asks whether more should be done to ensure X, the answer could be: yes, more should be done to ensure X; no, enough is being done to ensure X; no, X is bad and it should be removed, not promoted; it’s impossible to ensure X, and we can at most encourage X; etc.

‘This is the wrong question to ask’ or ‘a simple yes/no answer would be too simplistic’ can also be valid answers, but of course you will have to explain whatever your answer is.

Not everything is black-and-white

Be careful of extremes. For example: You might argue that discretion is bad because predictability is good. But one might as well argue that discretion is good because flexibility is good. Of course, the question of what we make of discretion is not just a binary question of whether it is ‘bad’ or ‘good’ — so don’t act as though it is.

There was an essay question about restorative justice. Strong essays ecognised that the question of whether restorative justice is to be embraced is not a binary one: the principles of restorative justice can bear different weights depending on contextual factors such as the severity of the crime, and a process is not hopelessly deficient merely because the role played by the victim is not the biggest possible. They also considered variations on the theme: they distinguished between (for example) making victim-offender mediation compulsory vs. encouraged vs. mandatory.

Consider what your aims are, and why they are your aims

Some argued that restorative justice would be a good thing because it would reduce recidivism. That may be true, but is it the only aim of restorative justice? Be careful not to send the message that the criminal justice system should pay more attention to victims, not for the victims’ sake as an end in itself, but as a means to the offender’s rehabilitation.

Meaningful comparisons

Suppose you are asked to consider whether Singapore’s Parliament should become more like the UK’s. Clearly, no person who suggests that could reasonably mean that (for example) the average height of the members of Singapore’s Parliament should be made closer to that of the members of the UK’s, or that Singapore’s MPs should dress more like MPs in the UK. Rather, in order to answer the question, one must consider: which aspects of the UK’s Parliament are the salient ones which one would even think are worth imitating?

Don’t rule out comparison because of differences that don’t, well, make a difference. Suppose you were making an argument about the AG’s prosecutorial functions. Could you say that a comparison with the UK would be inapposite, because there the AG doesn’t have prosecutorial functions? No, because the UK does have a public prosecutor, and you could very well compare Singapore’s AG qua public prosecutor with the UK’s public prosecutor (who is called the Director of Public Prosecutions). Of course it would be wrong to compare based on job titles: it would be difficult to make a meaningful comparison between, say, the President of Singapore and the President of the USA, because they are not even close to being functionally equivalent. But we can very well compare institutions which serve a similar function: it would make perfect sense to compare Singapore’s Prime Minister with the President of the USA, or Singapore’s President with the King of the UK, or Singapore’s AG qua PP with the UK’s DPP, or Singapore’s AG with the UK’s (AG plus DPP).

Different names for the same thing; the same name for different things

Sometimes, other legal systems use a term but use it to mean something else from how we use it. Take, for example, the phrase “strict liability” in criminal law. As far as I can remember, in English law, there is no general defence of due diligence to offences with no mens rea element; whereas, in Singaporean and Canadian law, there is, and if there were no due diligence defence then we would use the term “absolute liability”. In other words, what we would call an offence of “absolute liability”, the English would call an element of “strict liability”. So anyone who was writing an essay comparing strict liability offences in Singapore law and other legal systems would need to bear this in mind, searching for the functional equivalent of the Singaporean doctrine of strict liability elsewhere, and not merely searching for doctrines that are named “strict liability” elsewhere.

Similarly, it is possible that a label such as “the rule against fettering”, “natural justice”, etc. refers to something different in Singapore than in some other jurisdiction.

Seeing arguments, phenomena, etc. in context

In discussing cases in which novel arguments were made to courts, consider why these arguments may have been raised. For example, if I recall correctly, Prof Swati Jhaveri has made the point that perhaps what prompted the applicant in Chiu Teng to attempt to argue for a novel ground of judicial review was that $33 million (not a small sum) was at stake. What could prompt litigants to attempt to argue that an error of fact has taken place? or that taking the national pledge is a “ceremony in a religion”?

When making an observation about a phenomenon, consider the circumstances that may have given rise to that phenomenon. For example, it may be that the number of applications to the court of a certain sort has increased because something in the law has changed to make it easier to make such an application. Or it may be that the number of applications for judicial review has increased because the rate of regulatory activity by the executive / the range of executive powers created by the legislature has increased. Be careful not to consider only one possible explanation for a phenomenon to the exclusion of others. For example, as Chan CJ points out in ‘From Angst to Empathy’, the reason why judicial review applications sometimes fail is not necessarily that the law stacks the odds against the applicant; it could simply be that those applications are unmeritorious, or that there are other means by which disputes are resolved (see [14]ff). (A more prosaic example: one might be tempted to look at a (hypothetical) recent increase in rates of casino crime and conclude that the cause is moral decay in society, but the more accurate explanation might simply be that recently more casinos have come into existence.)

Assessing things

In assessing anything (an attempt, a balance, a rule, etc.), be sure to explain (and justify) what standard (sometimes colloquially called a ‘yardstick’) you are measuring it against. For example: if you say that a rule is “insufficient”, how are you measuring sufficiency, and why have you chosen that method of measurement?

In assessing a balance between A and B, you may consider not only the outcome of the balancing exercise, but also the method by which it is sought to be struck, as well as whether A and B are the correct things to balance in the first place.

How much detail should one go into?

In writing about any matter, the level of depth required is simply what would be relevant in answering the particular question. For example, if you are answering a question on whether the Chevron doctrine should apply in Singapore, it could be useful to discuss whether a particular difference between US and Singaporean constitutional law is an argument in favour or against Singapore law following Chevron. If it is necessary to provide some detail to explain what this difference is and why it is relevant, so be it. On the other hand, it would not be a good idea to engage in a bare discussion of the US Constitution without explaining how it is relevant to the question.

“It depends”

If your thesis is ‘it depends on X’, then you could consider organising your essay along the lines of the various possibilities. For example:

  • If X is A, then the conclusion is…
  • If X is B, then the conclusion is…
  • If X is C, then the conclusion is…
  • X cannot be A because…
  • That leaves B or C. X is now B… But in the longer term, X could change to C if…

Making assumptions

Suppose you think that an assumption would be questionable to make, and you say so. Can you then go on and rely on that assumption anyway? The answer is not necessarily no. It is perfectly fine to take one of the following views:

1. The assumption is open to challenge, but not on grounds that matter for present purposes
2. The assumption is open to challenge, but on balance I think it is justified / we’re better off sticking with it
3. I think X because the assumption is wrong. But even if we were to accept it, X is still true, because…

Of course, it depends on what you mean by “challenge”. It’s one thing if there are some possible arguments against making the assumption, but you can still see the value in accepting it (even if only reluctantly). But if (for example) the assumption is clearly very wrong, then one would think that any argument founded on that assumption must also be wrong. 

Problems and solutions

Some would have us believe that there is no use in one pointing out a problem if one doesn’t have a perfect solution. That is not true. Even explaining that a problem exists is a useful thing to do. Moreover, even if one cannot offer a complete, perfect, well-thought-out solution, it would still be helpful to offer some remarks about what a solution may look like, what a solution will require, etc.

Transplants

Sometimes, someone (e.g. a court) borrows one idea from one context and deploys it in another context. One way to respond may be to say that the idea is ill-suited to the latter context. But we should dig deeper and ask: Why would one even think to attempt such a transplantation? What is the transplanter trying to achieve?

When you are discussing a line of cases, don’t just comment on each case in isolation from the others, as though you are writing a series of case notes. Rather, consider saying something about how each case builds on/represents a break from the previous one; paves the way for the next one; contains the seeds of a problem which later presents itself; etc.

When you don’t know enough

If you think some kind of data would be useful in testing a hypothesis/answering a question, but that data isn’t available, and you have indeed put in the work to see if that data is available, then feel free to point that out — feel free to acknowledge gaps in knowledge, e.g. “… It does not help that there is no data about…” Consider inserting a footnote to state briefly what you did to find such data — that’s a way to rebut any objections from readers that you haven’t looked hard enough.

Confront hard cases

There was a question calling on students to discuss the idea that “religion and politics should not mix”. Some essays pointed out that there are religions which themselves teach the value of accommodation and tolerance of other religions. This is well and good, and it may appear that such a religion can sit comfortably within a framework of secular governance because there are few (if any) sites of potential conflict between the religious belief and the state goal. But consider:

  • If a religion tells believers that (say) God commands them to submit to secular state authorities, are the believers submitting because they think they should, or because God has told them to? If it is the latter – if the religion dictates that religion and state are separate – then one might argue that the religion purports to occupy a higher position in the hierarchy of norms, in that it is the religion that gets to say which norms are higher.
  • What if there is a religion that doesn’t teach that – say, a religion whose core belief is that other religions are wrong, that the state is to be resisted, etc.? It will not be so easy to say that everyone can just smile and get along.

“More should be done”

When answering a question about whether “more should be done” about something, consider: what is presently being done? If the answer is that nothing is being done, or that we don’t know, that itself can be a useful observation (provided that it’s accurate!)

“More should be done” — by whom?

Note that it’s possible to do something without identifying it by name. It’s possible for a legal system to have features of restorative justice without using that phrase. So don’t just, say, search the literature for “restorative justice” in Singapore and conclude that it doesn’t exist because nobody has used that phrase. Instead, consider what “restorative justice” means, and consider whether it exists/should be embraced in substance.

Ask yourself: Who cares, and why?

Essay questions generally do not call for the repetition of information, without more. That is not to say that information is not important; it is: an essay should not make assertions without substantiating them. However, the role of pieces of information is to support arguments. A good rule of thumb is to, whenever you write about a piece of information (such as some legislation or a case), to ask yourself why you are doing so and what the relevance to the topic is. Then make sure that, in your writing, you make clear what the relevance to the topic is. Better yet, state the relevance before narrating the information, so that the reader is told in advance what the main point is, rather than the main point emerging only toward the end.

The skills involved in dealing with an essay question are the same skills as those that come into play when you have to respond to someone who makes a loaded statement. Suppose you are making submissions to a court, and the judge remarks that what you are proposing sounds “anti-democratic”. The purpose of such a remark is, to quote Mohammed Ali bin Johari v PP [2008] 4 SLR(R) 1058 (CA) at [175(c)(iv)], to “assist counsel and their clients to be cognisant of what is troubling the judge”. At that point, what the judge wants to hear is not one case after another, but rather an explanation of why what you are saying is not, in fact, “anti-democratic”. A response to the judge’s remark would therefore need to engage with the concept of being “anti-democratic”.

Similarly, suppose you are arguing that your client was not given a fair hearing, and that you are required to engage with the assertion from the Dow Jones case at [59] that a hearing need not be given to a person who has “no right but simply a privilege” before that privilege is taken away. One possible tactic could be to cite cases that say that even one whose mere “privilege” is at stake is to be given a fair hearing. But another tactic could be to question what a “right” is, and to argue that your client did have a “right” at stake. Yet another could be to argue that, even though your client did not have a “right” at stake, he did have something more than a mere “privilege”. The skill of engaging with the concepts of ‘rights’ and ‘privileges’ and asking what these words mean, rather than merely citing cases which use these words, is the same skill that one has to exercise when responding to the assertion that the constitution “focus[es]” on A but neglects B.

“They Say/[but] I Say”

There is a book called They Say/I Say: The Moves That Matter In Academic Writing available in the library. Its main point is this:

“the underlying structure of effective academic writing — and of responsible public discourse — resides not just in stating our own ideas but in listening closely to others around us, summarizing their views in a way that they will recognize, and responding with our own ideas in kind. Broadly speaking, academic writing is argumentative writing, and we believe that to argue well you need to do more than assert your own position. You need to enter a conversation, using what others say (or might say) as a launching pad or sounding board for your own views.” (at page 3)

The writers note that “in the real world we don’t make arguments without being provoked”, and hence academic writing is not just a “process of saying ‘true’ or ‘smart’ things in a vacuum” (at page 3). So “[i]f your own argument doesn’t identify the ‘they say’ that you’re responding to, it probably won’t make sense” (at page 4).

The book provides many examples, but, for present purposes, one will suffice: at pages 4-5, the writers discuss Martin Luther King’s ‘Letter from a Birmingham Jail’:

“You deplore the demonstrations taking place in Birmingham. But your statement, I am sorry to say, fails to express a similar concern for the conditions that brought about the demonstrators.”

Advising a client (real or hypothetical) hen the law is not clear

  1. When the law is unclear, it is a good idea to point out the unclarity. Useful phrases might include:
    1. As can be seen from… it is unclear whether the test is A or B. However, it does not matter. If the test is A… If the test is B…
    2. … depends on whether the court holds that the test is A or B. If the test is A… whereas if the test is B…. Therefore, we should attempt to persuade the court that the test ought to be A, possibly on the grounds that, as pointed out by Professor Craig…
    3. While an argument may be made that the test ought to be A, there is little point pursuing the matter because Mr X would not succeed even on the more liberal A test…

Don’t use ambiguous words

Please be careful when using labels such as “light-touch”, “super-Wednesbury“, etc. Their meanings may be unclear and you may risk being misunderstood.  For example, as one of you pointed out, the term “super-Wednesbury” has been used by different authors to mean completely different things. The label “light-touch”, moreover, does not, as far as I can recall, appear in the case law (unlike the term “anxious scrutiny”); one therefore cannot assume that it will be understood as a term of art.

On a related note, please beware of the danger of using phrases which are clearly shorthand for something but do not make clear what that something is. A potential example we have come across is “rule of law” as used in popular discourse. Another is “due process”: exactly what kind of process are we saying is due to people?

‘Due’

The idea of a ‘right to due process’ ,without more, is circular, because to say that something is ‘due’ to you simply means that you have a right to it. The real question is: what kind of process is ‘due’, and why?

‘How’

If I ask you “How can I make good moussaka?”, all of the following could be possible answers:

  1. By following a recipe.
  2. By ensuring that I slice my eggplants longitudinally.
  3. With a little help from my friends.
  4. Carefully.
  5. With an oven.
  6. By being sure to use the best ingredients.

This is because ‘how?’ can mean many things, from ‘through what process?’ to ‘using what?’ to ‘by whom?’ to ‘in what manner?’ to ‘with what principles in mind?’

I would suggest bearing the many possible meanings of ‘how’ in mind when engaging with questions that ask ‘how?’.

Approaching questions critically

Essay questions in law schools are not meant to test one’s recall of knowledge, without more; this applies a fortiori to take-home research assignments and to questions asked as part of an open-book examination. Rather, the skill being tested is that of deploying pieces of knowledge to make arguments. It is therefore necessary to begin by commenting on precisely what one is being asked to argue about. This may well involve stating that the question is ambiguous or unclear; stating that the question is fallacious (for example, because it has been asked on the assumption that there is a strict dichotomy between X and Y, when in truth that dichotomy is a false one); or stating that the question makes multiple assertions, some of which are correct and others of which are not.

It is hoped that the following examples will illustrate possible lines of enquiry which one might pursue in response to a question:

  • “Is X too much…?” — How are we to measure the ‘amount’ of X? What is the ‘ideal amount’ of X?
  • “Assess X’s role in bringing about Y.” — How has X helped to bring about Y? Are there ways in which X has detracted from Y? What else has helped to bring about Y?
  • “… the doctrine of…” — What is that doctrine? Is there only one doctrine, or does it consist of multiple doctrines?
  • “… by design…” — Who is the designer? What were the designer’s aims? What other choices did the designer have?
  • “X is inherently anti-democratic…” — Is X inherently anti-democratic, or is it possible for X to be done in a non-anti-democratiic manner? Is there a difference between being anti-democratic and being non-democratic?
  • “… a court should defer to the expertise of the democratically elected, democratically accountable institution…” — Is that institution both democratically elected and democratically accountable? Is it always? What do democratic credentials have to do with “expertise”?
  • “X is undesirable because it is Y” — Is X undesirable? Is X Y? Is Y the reason why X is undesirable?

Miscellaneous feedback on particular essay assignments

In one year, I observed as follows:

The best essays squarely addressed the question asked through argument. Most essays did at least pay lip service to the question asked, in that they acknowledged certain terms used by the question that required a definition. Beyond this, what was needed was a sustained effort to address the question. Weak responses tended to say something about what the question meant, but then go on to discuss something not entirely related, only answering the question proper right at the end.

A number of essays went significantly over the word limit; marks were deducted for this, particularly when it was not necessary for the essay to go over the word limit in order to make the points that it sought to make. While no marks were deducted in respect of essays which were shorter than the word limit, it tended to be the case that these essays could have benefited from more detail.

In general, when answering questions such as the ones that had been asked, it is not a good idea to provide lengthy passages that state facts (including developments in the law) but do not explain what argument is being made using those facts. The strongest essays contained only a small section (if any at all) that contained an overview of certain facts. Instead, such essays were driven by arguments; facts were only used to support arguments. This approach meant that only relevant facts were stated, and no more. Weaker essays, by contrast, contained lengthy passages that narrated facts, but contained little analysis; the result sometimes came across more like an encyclopaedia entry than a paper that sought to advance an argument. 

While the word limit was a real challenge, it could often have been made easier to meet this challenge by condensing or eliminating passages that were merely descriptive so as to make room for analysis. 

Some essays contained lengthy passages devoted to summarising others’ ideas. The use of others’ ideas is, of course, not in and of itself wrong, but what is needed is an application of those ideas to the particular question asked.


In another year, I observed as follows:

The strong essays were well-researched (and some were very well-researched indeed).

They were organised sensibly so that the argument was easy to follow. There were signposts and transitions that guided the reader along a smooth path rather than making the reader bash through a dense jungle.

They contained well-substantiated arguments; there were no unjustified assumptions. For example, when they asserted that “many people” believed something, they cited a source to back that up. They did not assert that there is definitely causation when there is only evidence of correlation.

They did not just tell the reader facts; they used these facts to show the reader something, and they made clear to the reader what that thing was. At the same time, they did not make more of the facts than was justified: for example, they did not treat a single anecdote as though it were data.

They provided sufficient explanation to let the reader understand the significance of certain facts, while not dumping so much factual detail on the reader that the significance of those facts was lost. For example, strong essays did not name-drop [a government scheme] without explaining what that is; they did not just assert that a law does something, but rather went into detail about which part of the law does what, and precisely how; yet, when they stated the implications of Singapore entering into [an international treaty], they did not provide multiple paragraphs stating the law of international treaties in the abstract.

If they used slogans or platitudes, they took them as the starting point of analysis and unpacked them; when they did use slogans or platitudes as a conclusion, they argued for the conclusion, and did not treat them as self-evident; they recognised the eloquence and brevity of such statements without treating these attributes as necessary indicators of substantive soundness or correctness.

On the meaning of “begs the question”, see here.

Read questions carefully

Suppose there is a question about whether Article 15 of the Constitution (on freedom of religion) means that conscientious objection to national service should be recognised. That question is not merely about whether conscientious objection should be recognised; it is about whether it should be by reason of Art 15.

Whether something is “adequate”

When considering whether something has been “adequate”, there are at least three questions that we can consider asking:

  1. What is the thing whose adequacy we are measuring? (In the case of legislation, is it only the legislation itself, or also the process leading up to the enactment of the legislation?)
  2. What is/are the standard(s) (‘yardstick(s)’) by which to measure adequacy?
  3. How does the ‘thing’ measure up against those standards?

If you struggle with point 2, try asking about the different sources of standards. Who sets the standards by which X is judged? There are at least two possibilities to consider:

  1. Standards set by others.
  2. Standards set by X itself.

Taxonomy

Several of you have asked questions relating to taxonomy, e.g.: When a decision-maker takes into account irrelevant considerations, should we say that it has acted illegally or that it has acted irrationality? If proportionality is accepted as a ground of judicial review, is it a species of illegality; a species of irrationality; or something that exists alongside these categories? Is the law on procedural legitimate expectations better thought of as being part of the law of procedural fairness or part of the law of legitimate expectations? etc.

As in other areas of law (such as resulting trusts; constructive trusts; grounds on which restitution of unjust enrichment may be sought; and whether there are still such things as conditions and warranties in contract law), I am afraid that I can offer no easy answers. What I ask you to do is to consider why taxonomy matters.

Suppose you have two categories, A and B. Suppose you want to argue that the courts (/whoever) are wrong to say that X falls within category A; you want to say that X should fall within category B instead. What is the point of saying this? Is it just a matter of applying a label? Does it just mean that, if you were writing a textbook, you would write about X in chapter B instead of chapter A — a mere question of rearrangement? If so, then, one may ask: is there really any practical point in quibbling over categorisation?

An example on when categorisation does matter is this: when there is some rule (R) that applies to category A but not B. In that case, it makes a difference which category X is in, because that would make a difference as to whether rule R applies to X or not. Take, for example, the question of whether you would call a mushroom a “vegetable” or a “fungus”. Why does it matter? One reason why it matters is that, under section 7 of the Control of Plants Act, one needs a licence to “import for sale, supply or distribution” a “vegetable”.* That is one reason why classification matters. If I had not mentioned that statute, you might legitimately ask: who cares whether a mushroom is a “vegetable” or a “fungus”?**

Of course, remember that categories aren’t necessarily mutually exclusive. Something can be both a vegetable and a fungus.

One might ask: Isn’t intellectual honesty/neatness a good enough reason in and of itself to categorise something accurately? Perhaps. But that presupposes that intellectual honesty/neatness demands that there be multiple possible ways of categorising that thing in the first place. In other words, it would be somewhat pointless to stop at saying that a lime must be categorised differently from a lemon because they are different colours. This is because, one may ask: what is the point of classifying them by colour in the first place? Why not just have one category of ‘citrus fruits’ (or even just ‘fruits’) and be done with it?

More generally, when we design a system of taxonomy, it is because we have a certain aim in mind:

  • Is a tomato a fruit or a vegetable? It is probably the former in a system of classification designed to serve biologists, but the latter in a system designed to serve chefs.
  • Would it be useful to divide living things into three categories: “plants that are small and easy to care for at home”; “animals that are small and easy to care for at home; and “other living things”? This would be useless for biologists, but perhaps useful for a person who is seeking companionship and/or a sense of responsibility in life.

*For the avoidance of doubt, I express no view on whether a mushroom is a “vegetable” within the meaning set out in section 2 of the Act. 

**Yes, I know that the obvious answer is: “a biologist”. But I hope that the point I am trying to make is sufficiently clear.

Systems of taxonomy are not set in stone. Think of the classification of various types of plaintiff in occupiers’ liability cases in See Toh Siew Kee. There, the court said that the traditional classification into invitees, licensees, and trespassers arose for largely historical reasons, viz. that that classification arose before the idea of a general tort of negligence developed. Again, there was a time when Donoghue v Stevenson was seen as part of the law on liability for defective products rather than part of the general law of negligence. Similarly, on the account of Sedley in Lions Under the Throne, there was a time when what we would now call administrative law cases were once classified under the law of local government, the law of licensing, etc.

With this — the idea that taxonomies can change over time — in mind, think next of, say, the idea in Anwar Patrick Adrian that White v Jones may be seen as part of the Albazero line of cases. This was, at least to me, very interesting because it raises the issue of to what extent there is a rigid distinction between contract law and tort law.  The next question we should ask is: well, why is there this distinction in the first place? It would, of course, make a difference if we were trying to come up with a complete and doctrinally sound account of the law of obligations in Singapore generally (sed quaere, of course, whether such a category exists; or should the ‘law of obligations’ not be seen as distinct from the ‘law of property’? etc.) It might make a difference if there were some conflicts-of-laws issues involved laying down different rules for contractual vs. tortious claims. Again, it might make a difference if, hypothetically, the Limitation Act provided for different limitation periods for contractual claims and tortious claims. On the other hand, in the absence of such issues, it would not make a difference in a simple case in which you are trying to sue a lawyer who was negligent in drawing up a will: you would simply say to the court, ‘I should win because this case is analogous to Anwar Patrick Adrian‘.

Similarly, when would you need to ask about the classification of the grounds of review? If the classification makes no sense, you should feel uneasy, just as Daniel Tan, Paul Craig, Mark Elliott, et al. (and many, many others, whose works are too numerous to feature on our reading lists) have been bothered enough to be moved to write articles on such topics. At the same time, you should ask whether injustice is thereby done; or whether, despite doctrinal infelicities, one is able to go to court, say ‘That is Wednesbury unreasonable’, be more or less reasonably understood, and have justice done for one’s client. (I am not sure whether there is a clear answer to this question: I would leave it to you to form an opinion with the materials that we have.)

‘Checks and balances’

When you speak of ‘checks and balances’, consider: what risk is being checked against? So when you speak of replacing one ‘checking’ mechanism (A) with another (B), don’t only ask whether A is ‘more’/’less’ effective (as though you were comparing A and B quantitatively); ask: do A and B guard against the same kind of risks in the first place?

Even if someone can’t guarantee that something is prevented from happening, that person can still serve as a check against the risk of it happening. You can check against the risk of something happening, not only by making sure that it doesn’t happen, but also by making it harder for it to happen, making it slower to happen, nudging the person who makes it happen to reconsider their decision, making it more obvious to the public that it is happening, etc.

Changing from one thing to another

When you propose that something new be introduced, don’t just stop at commenting at the merits of that thing in and of itself; instead, consider the merits of that thing compared to the status quo. If someone is proposing introducing X, but we already have Y, and Y is a perfect substitute to X, then perhaps it is worth stating, not only that X is good (even if it is), but also that X is ultimately unnecessary.

When considering the possibility of changing from one thing to another, consider what would thereby be gained and what would thereby be lost.

Is there ever a reason to keep something that we know is sub-optimal, rather than replacing it? Possible reasons include:

  1. The process of change would be difficult/impossible
  2. We can’t think of a better way
  3. We can think of a better way, but we can’t implement it
  4. While the status quo is bad, the underlying aim it aims to achieve is good — so we should think of partial reform rather than replacement

Question: In light of limited space / limited time / the limited nature (if any) of the materials and case law available in Singapore, should questions be ‘read down’ / addressed narrowly?

Answer: You can make decisions as to your focus, but you cannot ignore parts of the question or change it.  (If I may, you may interpret the question, but must not in substance rewrite it.) In this regard, you may find it useful to explain, in your introduction, what you will (and will not) be focusing on and why.

On a related note: If a reasonable reader would think that a complete answer to the question must address A, B, and C, and if you only address A and B, then you should explain why you are not addressing C. Otherwise, one might get the impression that the paper does not completely answer the question because it doesn’t address C.

This is, by the way, similar to other general skills such as explaining one’s methodology and stating one’s assumptions.

What could be a valid reason for omitting C? Possibilities include the following (all of which, of course, would need to be substantiated):

  • At first glance C is relevant to the question, but actually it is not.
  • C is actually a subset of A and/or B.
  • The paper illustrates a broad principle. It is trite that that principle applies to C. What is less clear is whether the principle also applies to A and B. Therefore, the bulk of the discussion will focus on A and B.
  • C is theoretically relevant, but it hardly arises in practice.

Note that all of these require an explanation of why it is justifiable not to discuss C. It is not enough to say that you are not discussing C because of time/space constraints. This is because one might retort: if you want to save time and space, why not omit A or B instead of omitting C? Even if your aim is to save space, something needs to say about why C is the thing that is omitted in order to achieve this aim.

Choosing a case study to focus on

Some of you asked: Can I pick one specific case study to focus on? For example, in writing about educating people about Singapore’s constitution, can you just focus on one aspect of the constitution? In writing about restorative justice, can you just focus on cases involving one particular offence/type of offence/type of offender/type of victim?

The answer is: The questions speak in general terms, so ideally you should say something about the general point. However, you are free to focus on a small number of case studies — but use them to illustrate the general point. For example:

  • E presents an interesting case study in the complexities of doing X. A, B, C, and D are straightforward, but E (like F and G) shows that X is far trickier than appears at first glance.
  • It is useful to use A as a proxy for X generally. After all, A is the most common/most serious case of X / other cases like B, C, and D are similar to A.
  • It is clear that X encompasses A, B, and C. But how far can we push the idea? Would X also encompass D and E? This is useful because it tells us about the conceptual limits to X, and when it is time to shift focus away from X and toward Y instead.

The fact that you have space/time constraints is not itself a reason to focus on (say) A. It is a reason to focus on one thing, but one may ask: why A, and not B or C? Why compare the law of Singapore with that of (say) the UK, out of all the countries in the world? 

Consider whether a reader might criticise your choice of A as unrepresentative because A is an aberration.

You are free to discuss a hypothetical situation — say, to criticise a law because it would be insufficient to address the problems arising in a hypothetical case, C. But consider whether the reader might criticise your hypothetical example as being too far-fetched, unrealistic, implausible, etc. — and if so, consider pre-empting such an argument and responding.

On the other hand, don’t ignore outliers. That would be like saying that statelessness isn’t a problem in Singapore because there are only a few hundred stateless people compared to the total population of millions: a difficulty isn’t any less of a difficulty merely because few people face it; if you are tempted to think otherwise, imagine that you were one of those few hundred! It may be a policy choice to devote less resources toward tackling a problem faced by relatively few people, but that does not make it a small problem or a non-problem. 

(I’m going off on a tangent, but I’m reminded of this blog post by Gautam Bhatiacriticising a 2013 decision of the Supreme Court of India by which the court refused to declare their equivalent of Singapore’s former s 377A of the Penal Code unconstitutional. We don’t need to concern ourselves with the details, but one thing the Supreme Court said was that “a miniscule fraction of the country’s population constitute lesbians, gays, bisexuals or transgenders and in last more than 150 years less than 200 persons have been prosecuted (as per the reported orders) for committing offence under Section 377 IPC…” Bhatia had this to say:

“The Court then makes a truly bizarre observation, holding that because only 200 people have been prosecuted, there is no discrimination. Two hundred people. Suppose the State randomly catches hold of 200 people and shoots them dead. This, according to the learned Judge, would not be an Article 21 violation because, well, it’s just 200 people. Our Constitution does value human life – but only when it’s more than 200 people. Remember that.”

Please don’t hesitate to cite others’ work, quote from others, or state facts presented by others…

… but remember to do something with what you cite. You might say “Professor X says that Y because Z”, but explain how that figures into your argument: is Professor X correct? is her conclusion wrong because her methodology is wrong, or because her reasoning is fallacious, etc.? is her view inapplicable in Singapore because Z is not true in Singapore? does her view raise the question whether Y is true in Singapore, given that something like Z appears to be true in Singapore?

Also, sometimes there are limits to what you can infer from data — and that’s fine. Consider, for example:

  • “Professor X has found that in England, Y because Z. In Singapore, Z is not strictly true, but government statics suggest that something similar to Z appears to be true. This raises the question: is there the risk of Y in Singapore? 
  • Perhaps not, but we cannot dismiss the possibility. The stakes are high: [elaborate]
  • It is about time, then, that somebody conducted a study to see whether Z is true in Singapore. Of course, that is easier said than done. [elaborate]”

Making an original point that builds on others’ work

Even if your point is original but has drawn inspiration/support from elsewhere, it is perfectly fine to say so, acknowledging the support without detracting from the originality of the point. For example:

  1. “A discusses point X. His discussion of point X relies, in great part, on the doctrine of parliamentary sovereignty in the UK, which does not apply in Singapore. Nonetheless, in the Singapore context, one may modify point X by…”
  2. “In the context of discussing X, A states that… Taking this to its logical conclusion, in the case of Y…”
  3. “A points out that… But something more is needed to apply this line of thought in situation Y…”
  4. In a footnote: “Inspiration for this point is drawn from A, who states that…”
  5. “A similar point was first made by A, albeit in the context of…”

What does it mean to “critically discuss” a statement?

When you are directed to “critically discuss” a statement, you are free to not only to examine the issues raised in the statement, but also (if appropriate) express a view on the correctness of the statement. The point is to respond thoughtfully to the statement in a manner that you consider appropriate.

Question: To what extent is it necessary to define concepts mentioned in the questions? What if the very definitions of these concepts is questionable/contested/contestable?

Answer: In general, you should address the definitions of concepts mentioned in the question, particularly when your answer turns on these definitions. Also, in general, sometimes definitions are necessary by way of introduction; in other cases, the crux of the paper is really about what definition applies/ought to apply. If you have to choose one out of several possible definitions, then make clear that you are choosing and explain why that is your choice. Similarly, if the (possible) definition(s) is/are contestable, unclear, or of dubious utility, then say so and explain why. 

“If”

The word “if” is your good friend.

Consider: 

  • The first question is… The answer could be A or B. I think it is A because… If so, then… But if the answer is B, then that leads us into the next question… 
  • At first glance, that question is an important one. But it is actually immaterial. If the answer is A, then… But if the answer is B, we reach the same result, namely…
  • The answer really depends on what one means by “helpful”. If we take “helpful” to mean A then… On the other hand, if we take helpful to mean B, then… For present purposes, let us consider definition A. Definition B is superficially attractive, because… But the better view is that…
  • The law in Singapore is A, according to which the applicant’s claim would fail. But even if the law were B (as X has argued it should be), the applicant’s claim would still fail because…

If you think/write like this where appropriate, you will demonstrate both that you can express a view, and that you are capable of considering alternative views.

What kind of arguments can you raise when answering a hypothetical problem question?

Anything appropriate. In particular, when you are asked to pretend that you are arguing a case before a court (/advising someone as to whether to do so), you are free to:

  • state what the law is, and state how it would be applied
  • argue that a previously decided case should be distinguished, and hence has no relevance to the present case
  • argue that a previously decided case is wrong and should not be followed
  • argue that there is no established law on a certain matter, and then propose what the law should be

Of course, not all of these arguments will be equally readily accepted by a court. The third, in particular, has the limitation that a lower court is bound by a higher court’s decisions. So you should still try to use the skill of prioritising your arguments.

For these reasons, it is not true that, when answering a hypothetical question, you are bound only to state what the law is, and not what you think the law should be.  (And, even when you are doing the former, it is — as you should know by now — often far from straightforward what the law is.)

Question: Do you have to provide “both a thesis and anti-thesis”?

Answer: You simply have to write a good essay. A good essay, among other things, follows the following advice by Mark Elliott:

“In order to set out your argument in a persuasive manner, you need to deal both with relevant points that support your argument and with relevant points that appear to challenge your argument — and, in dealing with the latter points, you need to show why they do not in fact fatally undermine your argument. In other words, the approach I’m suggesting here doesn’t mean that you should adopt a blinkered approach, paying no attention to counterarguments: rather, you need to deal with them in a way that shows that, having thought about and weighed them in the balance, you are in a position to show why your argument stands in spite of them (or why your argument can be adapted in a way that accommodates such points).

All of this points towards a further matter: namely, that advancing an argument in your essay does not mean that you need to (or should) be argumentative in the sense of adopting a strident tone that brooks no debate or compromise. Rather, advancing an argument in the way I’ve suggested here means being thoughtful and persuasive: taking the reader with you on a journey that demonstrates that you have looked at the relevant material, carefully thought through the issues raised by the question, and arrived at a view that you are able to justify and defend through well-reasoned and suitably evidenced argument.”

This applies to writing all sorts of essays, including during an exam. 

I would add one more point: A “relevant poin[t] that appear[s] to challenge your argument” doesn’t necessarily mean a possible point that appears to totally contradict your argument. For example, you might concede that one of your arguments has a potential weakness, but that is not fatal to your argument; or you might point out that some of your arguments will hold only under certain conditions, but that those conditions are likely to hold; or you might say that the opposing position is not totally wrong, but just on balance less strong.

Similarly, sometimes, you might argue that a certain statement is not true, yet you might concede that the statement, while false on the whole, does contain a grain of truth.

If you are concerned about time constraints, remember that everybody is under time constraints; your task is not to write the best possible answers in the world, but rather to write the best answers you can write given time and other constraints.

General comments on style and grammar

It can be hard for the reader to keep track of idiosyncratic abbreviations.

Headings should guide the reader by providing a sneak preview of what each section or sub-section of the essay is about. Hence, a heading like “Evaluation” or “Short Answer” does not help much. 

While it is good for the introduction to provide a summary of the answer to the question, this can be done more elegantly than through a section labelled “Short Answer”.

A statement that “begs the question” is one that contains circular reasoning, in that it assumes (or merely asserts) what it purports to prove. “Begs the question” does not mean the same thing as “raises the question”.

Avoid dangling modifiers.

When you use a verb, you should generally make clear who is ‘doing’ the verb. The easiest way to do this is to make it a point to use the active voice (e.g. “The High Court said that…”) Using the passive voice (e.g. “It was said by the High Court that…”) is sometimes clunky, but not in and of itself wrong. What is undesirable is using the passive voice in a manner that does not mention the subject — for example:

  • “It was said that…” — who said?
  • “It is thought that” — who thinks?

If you are arguing something, there is no need to preface it with “It is argued that” or “This essay argues that” if the context makes clear that what you are saying is your argument and not someone else’s. For example, consider: “In X v Y, the High Court held that… But the High Court fell into the trap of A…” There is no need to say “It is argued that the High Court fell into the trap of A”. In fact, if you do say that, the reader is left to wonder who “argued that the High Court fell into the trap of A”.

Typically, an author defines certain words near the start of a piece of writing before proceeding to use those words. If you quote only the words but not the definition, the reader will often be left wondering what the words mean.

When quoting others’ words, use quotation marks or an indented block quotation. If you must change the original words, use square brackets. Use “emphasis in original”, “emphasis added”, or “emphasis removed” as necessary.

For example, if I said “I want to go to the zoo.”, you could write:

Ong said that he “want[ed] to go to the zoo”.

Be wary of online citation generators, which can produce results that are not useful to the reader (for example, citations that do not tell the reader where a certain article might be found, or when a certain website was published). Instead, I recommend that you try to learn a style such as the SAL style or OSCOLA and get into the habit of producing citations manually; doing so will soon become second nature, which will be particularly useful if you go into litigation.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *