Benjamin Ong's notes

Notes about Singapore public law, etc. for my students (and possibly others)

Organising an essay: an example

It is not necessarily the case that one needs to (a) spend about a paragraph at the beginning of the essay defining the terms used in the question; (b) use the rest of the space to answer the question. It may well be that far more than an introductory paragraph or two may be necessary to provide definitions. In fact, it may well be that the entire essay is an exercise in definition. If, for example, you are asked whether judicial review is anti-democratic, your essay might take the following form:

  1. It depends what is meant by ‘anti-democratic’…
  2. First, ‘anti-democratic’ could mean having the aim of undermining democratic processes. By this measure, judicial review is not anti-democratic.
    1. One might think it is anti-democratic. After all…
      1. Case study
      2. Case study
    2. However, in truth…
      1. Case study
      2. Case study
  3. One might instead say that ‘anti-democratic’ refers to having the effect of undermining democratic processes.
    1. This is not necessarily the case.
      1. Case study
      2. Case study
    2. That said, there are situations in which judicial review has the effect of…
      1. Case study
      2. Case study
  4. Is judicial review being ‘anti-democratic’ in this limited sense justified? ‘Anti-democratic’ connotes something undesirable… So it might be misleading to apply the label ‘anti-democratic’ if there are good reasons for the law to de-prioritise democratic ideals or the wishes of a democratically-elected body.
    1. Good reasons might include…
      1. Reason A
        1. Case study
      2. Reason B
        1. Case study
      3. But not reason C
        1. Case study
    2. Even then, judicial review would be ‘anti-democratic’ in the sense of undermining democratic ideals/institutions in certain discrete instances, but that is justified as a means to promoting the broader ideal of democracy…
  5. Conclusion:
    1. The label ‘anti-democratic’ is misleading because… Instead, a better label is…
    2. All this having been said, I have explained why one might be tempted to label judicial review ‘anti-democratic’. The law needs to pay attention to X, Y, and Z to avoid being what I have described as being undesirably anti-democratic.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *