“CRuPAC”, “IRAC”, etc. are useful guides to thought, in that they remind us that law is a mode of doing justice by reference to rules: “the only justice that can be attained by mortals, who are fallible and are not omniscient, is justice according to law; the justice which flows from the application of sure and settled principles to proved or admitted facts” (Cowcher v Cowcher [1972] 1 WLR 425 (EWHC) 430).
But they are not necessarily useful guides to writing, in that, if unthinkingly followed in a formulaic manner, they can lead to writing that is tedious, clunky, and simply not space-efficient.
While we need to be clear about what separate issues exist (and how to divide a problem into issues can itself be debatable), what the relevant rule is (which can itself be debatable), and what the rules have to say about the relevant facts (which can itself be debatable), there is no need to insist on devoting (say) X sentences or Y paragraphs to each of them. In fact, it may be possible to say all one needs to say about them in just one paragraph.
If one is not misled by red herrings (if any), avoids being unnecessarily verbose, avoids spending too much space discussing trite/undisputed issues, and instead focuses on the more contentious issues, one will be able to produce a meaningful answer to the questions that will be asked.
I propose to illustrate all this with some examples from my old business law course materials. (I have chosen to ensure that I am providing suggestions as to style, not content. Of course, a deeper level of detail may be warranted.)
Example 1
“There is a contract between A and B: there have clearly been offer, acceptance, consideration, and intention to create legal relations. Has it – in particular, clause 3 – been breached? The problem is that the word “X” in clause 3 is ambiguous. Hence, we must interpret clause 3, in light of…, with a view to determining the parties’ intentions at the time the contract was made (Zurich v B-Gold). The question is whether the word “X” mean P or Q. Given the conversation between the parties, it would appear that both parties proceeded on the basis that the word “X” mean P.
If this is correct, then the contract has been breached as what was delivered is clearly Q. On the other hand, if interpretation Q is correct, then the contract has been performed exactly as promised, and B may not sue A for breach of contract although B feels disappointed.
If the contract has been breached, then what are the consequences? Damages are payable, calculated according to the rule that… If the contract had been performed… Now, however… Therefore, the sum of damages payable is…
As there are no outstanding obligations under the contract, it does not matter whether or not B has a right to terminate the contract.”
This example identifies one issue: whether a contract exists. But it swiftly states the rule (in few words), applies it, and states the conclusion. It then segues into a second issue: whether the contract has been breached. To address that issue, we must first address a third issue: the interpretation of clause X. We have stated a rule on interpretation, applied it, and posited two possible conclusions. Those two conclusions then lead to two possible answers to the second issue. We then move to discuss a fourth issue (the consequences) of breach; but we are careful to state clearly that this issue only arises if the contract has been breached. This may be divided into two parts: damages, and termination. We address the first part, again using our classic “IRAC” model. As for the second part, we have explained why it is actually not an issue, and hence no further discussion is required.
Example 2
Consider the following example. It uses the “IRAC” structure, but does not rigidly write “The issue is… The rule is… Applying the rule…” Instead, it addresses all 4 points – not necessarily in order, but still smoothly – and does so in a way that uses relatively few words, while discussing multiple issues and the relation between them:
“[Issue:] If A is liable for breach of contract, he will claim that his liability has been excluded by an exemption clause contained on a sign on the wall. [Conclusion:] It is unlikely that his liability has been excluded as [Rule:] the sign could not reasonably have come to the notice of B, [Application:] having been put in an obscure location and in small print. [Issue:] Even if it had been excluded, [Conclusion:] it is unlikely to apply in favour of A: [Rule + Application:] the word “consequences” on the sign is ambiguous (does it include breach of contract?) and the [Rule + Application:] contra proferentem rule suggests that it will be interpreted in B’s favour.”
Example 3
“In any event, the exclusion clause, even if incorporated into the contract, probably falls foul of section 3 of the UCTA. As mentioned above, the requirements in sections 1 and 3(1) are met. However, it is doubtful whether the exclusion clause meets the ‘requirement of reasonableness’ because…”
Leave a Reply