I would prefer to say no, because saying yes would mean that the High Court had defied no fewer than three Court of Appeal cases. Rather, I think that the High Court’s decision is compatible with the standing test in Tan Eng Hong etc. What had been ‘broadened’, if anything, was the sense of what the Art 15 right consists of. In granting the 3rd applicant (the spectator/photographer) standing, the High Court effectively held that watching/photographing a religious procession is an act of “practice” of that religion.
On the other hand, this is not a very great expansion. Consider the implication in Colin Chan that a mere ‘citizen’ who follows the Jehovah’s Witnesses religion would have had standing: “He does, however, have a constitutional right to profess, practise and propagate his religion, and it is alleged that the publications by IBSA are essential for him to carry out these activities.” To the extent that this means that a ‘mere’ reader of these materials would have had standing, it is not that much of a stretch to say that, in Thaipusam, a ‘mere’ viewer would have had standing.
Leave a Reply