Benjamin Ong's notes

Notes about Singapore public law, etc. for my students (and possibly others)

Equality in sentencing

A student asked: Suppose the Public Prosecutor argues that A and B should get life imprisonment. However, A is older than B, so the sentence of life imprisonment would have a greater impact on A. How does the concept of equality fit into all this?

My response:

What is the role of the PP?

In this situation, the PP’s ‘decision’ to make various submissions about the sentences has no legal effect.

That is because the arguments that the PP chooses to make in court don’t have a direct effect on the punishment imposed by the offender. The decision as to the sentence is the court’s alone; the court is not bound to impose a certain sentence (or a sentence from a certain range) merely because the Prosecution submits that such a sentence would be appropriate. See Janardana Jayasankarr v PP [2016] SGHC 161 at [10]-[12]; AG v Wham Kwok Han Jolovan [2019] SGHC 111 at [88] (not disturbed on appeal: [2020] SGCA 16).

(Similarly, the court is not bound to impose the sentence recommended by, say, a probation suitability report: Praveen s/o Krishnan v PP [2017] SGHC 324 at [65]-[66].)

Because of this, to the extent that the chain of causation has been started by the PP, it is broken by the court’s independent sentencing decision. In other words, if anyone can be accused of violating Art 12(1), it is not the PP, but the court (or possibly the Minister for Home Affairs – see below).

By the way, while the Prosecution of course has discretion as to what submissions on sentencing to make, we typically don’t call this “prosecutorial discretion”; we use that term to refer only to the prosecution’s discretion as to what charges, if any, to tender against someone.

What does the ideal of equality before the law require of the court?

 Same offence – same sentence for both offenders…

The court gives effect to Art 12(1) in sentencing through what is known as the “parity principle” (see e.g. Chong Han Rui v PP [2016] SGHC 25, [1] – refers to parity between two co-offenders in the same criminal enterprise) and the general principle of “consistency in sentencing” (see the source cited in Lim Bee Ngan Karen v PP [2015] SGHC 183 at [30]). (That said, the courts tend not to mention Art 12(1) by name when discussing these principles, but that doesn’t change the analysis.)

That said, in applying these principles, the courts do take into account that the two offenders might not be equally situated: for example, there may be a “relevant difference in [the two offenders’] responsibility or their personal circumstances”: see Muhamad Azmi bin Kamil v PP [2022] SGCA 68, [25]. In short, the law is that offenders who are equally situated should receive the same sentence; but offenders may not be equally situated, for various reasons.

… or, rather, same impact on both offenders?

The courts do also consider that a sentence of a certain length may have a disparate impact on people with different ages or different health conditions. This is known as the “principle of equal impact”: see M Raveendran v PP [2021] SGHC 254 at [15] onwards; Chew Soo Chun v PP [2016] SGHC 6 at [59] onwards.

So life imprisonment for two prisoners, with a different impact on each of them, may be justified or not depending on the sentencing objective. I would however add that the sentencing objective for each of them could well be different, itself because of differences between the offenders’ circumstances etc.

(Of course, the court is ultimately constrained by the range of possible sentences set out in the legislation.)

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *