Benjamin Ong's notes

Notes about Singapore public law, etc. for my students (and possibly others)

Various words and phrases relating to the powers of the state

‘Separation of powers’

When discussing the concept of separation of powers, it would be useful to distinguish between (a) saying something about the fact that the powers are separated; (b) saying something about what exactly those powers are. For example, some might seek to argue that judicial review of administrative action on the ground of irrationality is a violation of the principle of separation of powers. But what does this mean? If, for example, there is a legal rule that the executive has no power to be irrational, then the court’s examining decisions and quashing them if they are found to be irrational is no breach of the separation of powers.

‘Institutional competence’

When discussing institutional competence, it may be useful to distinguish between absolute and relative institutional competence. Some of you asked: why is it said that the courts ought to abstain from judicial review in areas which engage polycentric socio-economic considerations, while the courts have no hesitation about developing the law on (say) vicarious liability, which has potentially significant impact on all manner of areas of life (e.g., to take just one example, the demand for insurance)? The answer may be that, in the field of vicarious liability, the courts are free to develop the law as they see fit, because, if not them, who else? The same cannot be said of areas where there is a statute regulating the topic in question, because the answer to ‘who else?’ is ‘the Legislature’.

‘Accountability’

Various writers have made the point that ‘accountability’ does not merely mean giving an account. Anne Davies, for instance, writes of accountability as a process from someone (who?) setting standards, to obtaining an account (in what level of detail?), to someone (who?) judging the account against the standards, to some response to the findings. For more details, you may wish to consider:

  1. Anne Davies, Accountability: A Public Law Analysis of Government by Contract (OUP, 2001) 
  2. Nicholas Bamforth and Peter Leyland (eds), Accountability in the Contemporary Constitution (OUP, 2013) — available at the National Library
  3. Various works by Dr Ellen Rock, which are listed on her profile page: https://www.uts.edu.au/staff/ellen.rock

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *