A case in which a judge decided to recuse himself is Ong Wui Teck v Ong Wui Swoon [2016] 2 SLR 1067 (HC). Ong Wui Teck, a party who was acting in person, applied for Woo Bih Li J to recuse himself. Woo J held that no cause for recusal had been made out. Nonetheless, he recused himself:
“I decided to recuse myself not because there was any merit in Mr Ong’s allegations against me but because, in the interest of justice, I was of the view that I should not hear his disputes with Mdm Ong in respect of the mother’s estate since I was contemplating making a complaint about Mr Ong’s conduct to the appropriate authorities.” (at [81])
In this regard, it is useful to note the remarks of Choo Han Teck J in Re Raffles Town Club Pte Ltd [2008] 2 SLR(R) 1101 (HC) at [7], which Ong Wui Teck had cited:
“A fair, honest, and impartial judge or member of a quasi-judicial body may be indignant that anyone should think him otherwise. But sometimes reasonable suspicion may arise from a mix of circumstances and unfamiliarity with the reputation of the judge or member of a quasi-judicial body. Under such circumstances, the judge or member of a quasi-judicial body concerned should recuse himself from the case should there be a genuine concern regarding his connection with the case or a party to the case. There is little else he can do. For instance, if he were to swear an affidavit to explain the circumstances and give a full account of the circumstances such as to show that he really has no grievance that might affect his judgment, he might still not fully remove all trace of odour from the air of impartiality. Indeed, the more he seeks to justify his position, the stronger the smell may grow. Hence, a judge or quasi-judicial officer in these circumstances will likely recuse himself and pre-empt any cause for concern.”
I also mentioned in class that I thought it very unlikely that a recusal application could amount to contempt of court. I wish to clarify that I meant that the mere act of making a recusal application, without more, will generally not amount to contempt. But as the Ong Wui Teck case shows, the manner in which the application is made, or the (purported) grounds on which it is made, can amount to contempt of court. As the Court of Appeal said ([2020] 1 SLR 855 at [29]):
“The Allegations arose out of the appellant’s recusal application. An applicant in a recusal application would naturally be required to set out the reasons he thinks justify a recusal. This may include an apprehension of bias. A recusal application is, however, not carte blanche or a “get out of jail free” card for an applicant to say what he pleases without any consequence. Any allegation made by an applicant in a recusal application must be backed by some evidence, or at the minimum, supported by rational basis. If so, such allegations will not attract liability for contempt, though whether they will actually succeed in securing a recusal would be another issue. An applicant cannot exploit a recusal application as an opportunity to engage in sarcasm or to violently abuse or ridicule a judge. The Judge opined, and we agree, that criticisms coloured to the extent that they attract the law of contempt will not be protected under the realm of recusal.”
The Court of Appeal added (at [35]):
“In a recusal application where the judge considers that the applicant’s assertion of bias has no basis and the applicant has made contemptuous allegations, the judge is placed in a very difficult position. If the judge dismisses the application, he may have reservations that the public may think he is biased. Yet, a judge will not want to be a judge in his own cause especially when the assertions of bias are so repeated and vituperative as to cause the judge to suspect that there has been a contempt of court. In these circumstances, it may be prudent for a judge intending to file a formal complaint of contempt against a party, to recuse himself from hearing matters relating to that party. This is at least until the conclusion of the inquiry or any proceedings arising from that complaint. It is prudent because it removes any suspicion of bias on the part of the judge, strengthens public perception of judicial impartiality and prevents the unnecessary protraction of litigation and wastage of resources arising from further recusal applications. This is not to say that in all situations where an application for recusal is made that the Judge should recuse himself or herself. It all depends on the circumstances of the case.”
(For the avoidance of doubt, I am not related to any of the parties in the Ong Wui Teck case.)
Leave a Reply