Benjamin Ong's notes

Notes about Singapore public law, etc. for my students (and possibly others)

Constitutional amendments

There is always a tension between the idea that a constitution (/Constitution) is meant to be enduring and the idea that it is meant to reflect what society holds important: what if the latter changes?

One could attempt to calculate the ‘amendment rate’ of a Constitution. But numbers alone can be misleading. An ‘amendment rate’ would say nothing about the content or extent of the amendments. (Might it be, or example, that a change to the fundamental rights provisions would be of more moment than, say, a change to the name of a court?) Nor would it consider the various reasons for differences in ‘amendment rate’. One would be the vintage of the Constitution in question: one might think that a Constitution that has existed for a long time has already undergone all the amendments that the people want; on the other hand, it could also be that a jurisdiction has not amended its Constitution much (or at all) because it frequently replaces (or has recently replaced) its Constitution. Another would be the set of rules contained in the Constitution compared to other documents: for example, a legal system could have some — indeed, many — constitutional rules contained elsewhere than in the Constitution (consider, for example, how Singapore’s rules on the mechanism of voting for MPs are largely contained in the Parliamentary Elections Act and not the Constitution). 

Therefore, an ‘amendment rate’ would, without more, not necessarily be an appropriate basis on which to think that some other jurisdiction is/isn’t similar to Singapore. One could attempt to, say, calculate the number of amendments per unit time, per capita, etc.; but this may or may not be sufficient to consider all the factors that determine the frequency, nature, and extent of the frequency of amendment.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *