Benjamin Ong's notes

Notes about Singapore public law, etc. for my students (and possibly others)

The President and ceremonies

The President not only exercises duties set out in the Constitution, but also duties which involve the President acting as a symbol. I do not mean that the President’s symbolic role is in reality unimportant, nor that her role ought to be only that of a number-checking, bill-scrutinising administrator. To the contrary, presenting a good impression, on the domestic and international stages, by performing symbolic, ceremonial duties, and by interacting meaningfully with members of the local and international community, is very important. True, there is no way to quantify how much more has been raised through the President’s Challenge, or how much better regard other states have held us in, as a result of the President’s efforts. (Consider: why does the President’s Challenge exist, and why is it successful at raising funds even though many other charitable drives exist?  The answer, to my mind, is that the President is truly capable of operating as a unifying image, and that this image is truly of utility in serving the common good.) These duties are not even set out in the Constitution. But there is much that is important that is not set out in the Constitution, and there is much that is important that is unquantifiable; yet it is still important.

If I may put it another, more colloquial, way: in my view, the President’s job may be described as involving a show, but not a mere show. To the extent that the President’s job involves a show that is meant to be seen – and it does – that show is an important show. It is as important as the show that consists of the judges wearing their ceremonial red robes at the Opening of the Legal Year ceremony or the Serjeant-at-Arms marching into Parliament with the mace. These shows serve a purpose, because they prompt people to respond in a certain manner. They prompt people to share in an air of solemnity surrounding proceedings that affect the lives of millions; and to pause and think about how those lives are being affected. These ceremonies involve officers dressing and taking part in processions in a manner unlike that of ordinary people because the roles they play are quite unlike those of ordinary people. 

I would also venture to suggest that ceremonies are directed not only at the observing public, but also at the officials themselves.

I suppose that some of this is outside the domain of the lawyer, and perhaps within the domain of the sociologist or anthropologist. Consider, for example, the body of scholarship about visual images of judges (http://blogs.bbk.ac.uk/research/2014/09/30/judicial-images/; https://www.jstor.org/stable/43862420). 

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *