Benjamin Ong's notes

Notes about Singapore public law, etc. for my students (and possibly others)

How a Bill becomes law

For a quick overview of how a Bill becomes law, see this note on Parliament’s website: https://www.parliament.gov.sg/parliamentary-business/glossary/Details/passage-of-a-bill/Passage%20of%20a%20Bill. 

For more details, including examples, note the following:

Second Reading stage

A Bill is debated at the Second Reading stage. The purpose of Second Reading debates is to discuss the “general merits and principle of the Bill” (Standing Order 70(2)). 

Committee stage

After that, the Bill goes through the Committee stage. The purpose of the Committee stage is “not [to] discuss the Principle of the Bill but only its details” (Standing Order 72(1)). 

Usually, at the Committee stage, Parliament resolves itself into a Committee (or, in full, a “Committee of the whole Parliament”) on the Bill. The Bill is then scrutinised clause by clause and MPs can propose amendments to specific clauses. For an example of this, see the debates on the Miscellaneous Offences (Public Order and Nuisance) (Amendment) Bill in February 1996: https://sprs.parl.gov.sg/search/topic?reportid=011_19960227_S0003_T0007. At column 704 onwards, we see that during the Committee stage, Prof Walter Woon — then an NMP — proposed several amendments. Eventually Parliament did not vote in favour of any of these proposed amendments (“Amendment negatived.”), but the proposed amendments were debated.

Instead of a Committee of the whole Parliament, Parliament may resolve to commit the Bill to a Select Committee on the Bill. This consists of a small number of MPs, which examines the Bill, may receive representations from the public, and eventually produces a report recommending changes to specific clauses, if any. The report is then placed before Parliament.  To access Select Committee reports, see here: https://sprs.parl.gov.sg/selectcommittee/home. The most recent Select Committee on a Bill to have issued its report appears to be the Select Committee on the Cross-Border Railways Bill. For an interesting read on the jury system, see the Report of the Select Committee on the Criminal Procedure Code (Amendment) Bill presented to Parliament on 9 December 1969.

An aside: Select Committees that don’t pertain to Bills

(You will notice that not all Select Committees pertain to Bills. Indeed, a Select Committee is simply, as the Parliament website puts it, “[a] group of Members selected by Parliament to inquire into and report on a particular subject” (https://www.parliament.gov.sg/parliamentary-business/glossary/Details/select-committees/Select%20Committees) — there are Select Committees on Bills, but also on other topics (e.g. the Standing Select Committee on Nominations for Appointment as Nominated Members of Parliament; the Select Committee on Deliberate Online Falsehoods).)

Third Reading stage

After the Committee stage comes the Third Reading stage, at which MPs may only propose “[a]mendments for the correction of errors or oversights”, and not “amendments of a material character” (Standing Order 81(2)). 

PCMR

For PCMR reports, go to the National Archives website (https://www.nas.gov.sg/archivesonline/search) and search for “Presidential Council for Minority Rights”, then click “Government Records”. 

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *