Benjamin Ong's notes

Notes about Singapore public law, etc. for my students (and possibly others)

Can the President be compelled to give evidence in court?

Can the President of Singapore be compelled to give evidence in a witness in court proceedings? Answering this question has brought me down a delightful rabbit-hole, the contents of which I would now like to share with you.

It would be useful to begin with the law in the UK. According to Halsbury’s Laws of England, there are two relevant rules. First, “A monarch has immunity at common law from being compelled to give evidence in court”.1 Second, “the monarch may not give evidence in her own cause”2 – for example, the monarch cannot give evidence in cases involving alleged crimes against the monarch, such as treason.3

Robin Callender Smith has questioned whether these are really accurate statements of the law in the UK. He has argued that they are not necessarily so, and hence has criticised the decision in the case of Edward Mylius.4 In that case (decided in 1911), Mylius was convicted of having committed criminal libel against King George V, by publishing material alleging that he had a secret second wife. The Lord Chief Justice, Lord Alverstone, agreed with counsel for the Attorney-General that the court could not issue a subpoena to compel the King to give evidence.5

By the way, since then, Callender Smith has also called attention to the case of Paul Burrell. Burrell was a butler who was charged with stealing various items from members of the royal family. However, the prosecutors halted the prosecution after receiving a statement by the Queen that she had given those items to Burrell for safekeeping. Evidently, the prosecution took the view that the Queen could not be compelled to give evidence. Callender Smith is presently attempting, under the UK’s Freedom of Information Act, to get more details on the reasons for the prosecution’s view.6

One might think that, assuming the law of the UK is as set out above, Singapore would have corresponding rules relating to the President. I sreiously doubt this. The foundation of the rules in the UK appears to be the idea that the courts are, formally speaking, Her/His Majesty’s courts, and the monarch cannot be compelled by his/her own courts. Moreover, the monarch would be free to ignore a subpoena, given that the monarch “can do no wrong”. These ideas are alien to Singapore. Singapore’s Constitution does not say that the President “can do no wrong”. This is unlike, say, Malaysia’s Federal Constitution, which states that the Yang di-Pertuan Agong and the Rulers “shall not be liable to any proceedings whatsoever in any court”,7 and which explicitly preserves the Rulers of the states’ “sovereignty, prerogatives, powers and jurisdiction”.8 Moreover, Singapore’s Constitution does not say that the courts are “the President’s courts”. The President is not above the courts, not vice versa. Finally, I know of no statutory provision stating that the President may not be compelled to give evidence in court; this is in contrast to jurisdictions like Brunei where such a provision exists.9

But even if the abovementioned rules in the UK could in principle apply to the President of Singapore, they could not apply in a case where the President is willing to give evidence without being compelled to do so.

Callender Smith’s article also quotes a letter by Sir Arthur Bigge, personal secretary to King George V, which suggests that the Government could “declin[e] to allow His Majesty to appear”.10 I do not know about the precise basis for this power in the UK (assuming it exists). This does, however, prompt the question: Could the Government, or anyone else, stop the President from giving evidence if the President is willing to do so?

When sections 4A-4B of the Attorney-General (Additional Functions Act), which were recently inserted by the Courts (Civil and Criminal Justice) Reform Act 2021, come into force, the AG will have the power to intervene in civil proceedings in the public interest. The power to intervene is not new law; it reflects the common-law position that the Attorney-General can (with the leave of court) intervene in civil proceedings in order to assert “public interest privilege”.11 In the 2019 ARW case, the Court of Appeal used that phrase to refer to rule in s 126 of the Evidence Act; here, we are concerned with s 126(1) which provides: “No public officer may be compelled to disclose communications made to him or her in official confidence when he or she considers that the public interest would suffer by the disclosure.” One might ask: what if the President is nonetheless willing to disclose such communications, or to give any other sort of evidence, without being compelled to do so? I believe the answer may lie in the common-law doctrine of public interest immunity,12 which, it stands to reason, the AG would be entitled to intervene in civil proceedings to invoke.

Finally, what if the AG and the President (and/or, for that matter, the Government) take different views on whether the doctrine of public interest immunity is to be invoked? I would submit that the position is as follows. It appears that public interest immunity may be invoked by an executive officer in his own right,13 so the AG might not have the power to overrule that executive officer and decline to invoke the doctrine. As for the opposite situation – the executive officer doesn’t want to invoke the doctrine, but the AG does – I would submit that the AG would have the final say, given that it is the AG and not the President whom the courts have described as being the “guardian of the public interest”14 in this sense. If I am right, then, in this latter case, any clash between the AG, the Government, and/or the President on when to claim public interest immunity is a matter to be resolved behind the scenes rather than in court.

  1. Halsbury’s Laws of England, vol 29 (Crown and Crown Proceedings, 2019), para 64. ↩︎
  2. Ibid. ↩︎
  3. Joseph Chitty, ‘A Treatise on the Law of the Prerogatives of the Crown’, 377, cited ibid. ↩︎
  4. Robin Callender Smith, ‘The Missing Witness? George V, Competence and Compellability and the Criminal Libel Trial of Edward Frederick Mylius’ (2012) 33 Journal of Legal History 209 <https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2037498>. ↩︎
  5. Ibid, SSRN page 24. ↩︎
  6. Robin Callender Smith, ‘Will we discover when the Queen can be required to give evidence in court?’, Inforrm, 9 July 2019 <https://inforrm.org/2019/07/09/will-we-discover-when-the-queen-can-be-required-to-give-evidence-in-court-robin-callender-smith/>. (It is interesting to note the comments by one Tony Adler on this blog post; Adler claims to set out situations in which members of the Royal Family appeared as witnesses in court.) ↩︎
  7. Federal Constitution of Malaysia, Art 32(1) and 181(2). Even then, there are exceptions to this: see Art 182-183. ↩︎
  8. Ibid, Art 181(1). ↩︎
  9. Supreme Court Act (Brunei) s 34(1), cited in Prince Jefri Bolkiah v State of Brunei Darussalam [2008] 2 LRC 196 (PC) [11]. That case cited the Mylius case, and was cited in Callender Smith, ‘The Missing Witness?’, above, fn 110. ↩︎
  10. Callender Smith, ‘The Missing Witness?’, above, at 23. ↩︎
  11. ARW v Comptroller of Income Tax [2019] 1 SLR 499 (CA) [24]-[28]. ↩︎
  12. Mah Kiat Seng v AG [2021] SGHC 202. ↩︎
  13. Ibid, [90]. ↩︎
  14. ARW (above) [24]-[25], cited in Mah (above) [58]. ↩︎

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *