Strictly speaking, this is the wrong question to ask. “[I]t is important to remember that the decision ruling out such documents [or evidence more generally] is the decision of the Judge… It is the Judge who is in control of the trial, not the Executive”: Duncan v Cammell Laird [1942] AC 624, 642. So the question is: when may the Executive attempt to withhold evidence from production in court on the ground of the “public interest”, and when may the court allow such an attempt?
There are at least two relevant legal rules.
First, there is section 126(1) of the Evidence Act: “No public officer may be compelled to disclose communications made to him or her in official confidence when he or she considers that the public interest would suffer by the disclosure.” As we should know by now, the words “when he or she considers that…” do not mean that the public officer can refuse to disclose evidence of the communications on his/her own say-so. To the contrary, “the relevant public officer does not have an unfettered discretion to determine that the public interest would suffer by the disclosure of the relevant communications”: Chiu Teng Enterprises Pte Ltd v AG [2011] SGHC 77, [8]. Therefore, “the court can review the legality of a determination of public interest under s 126(1) on the usual grounds known to administrative law”: ibid. (See also Mah Kiat Seng v AG [2021] SGHC 202, [96].)
Note that s 126(1) refers to “communications” made to a public officer: see e.g. Mah at [15]-[16].
Note also that the state may waive the right to rely on s 126(1): see, for example, Mah at [91]-[95]. In that case, certain footage from a police officer’s body-worn camera showed someone making a report to that officer. That was a recording of “communications” made to a “public officer”, so s 126(1) applied. However, the AG “unilaterally [gave] a limited waiver of s 126”; it was willing to disclose the footage to Mah, but subject to the restrictions set out at [95] (for example, that the complainant’s identity be redacted).
Second, there is common-law public interest privilege: “Documents which ought otherwise to be disclosed under the rules of civil or criminal procedure may only be withheld if the court concludes that the public interest against disclosure outweighs the public interest in the administration of justice.”: Mah Kiat Seng at [80]. This appears to be a flexible doctrine, in that the court will consider whether the reasons weighing against disclosure can be satisfied through the use of “appropriate safeguards”: at [99]. In that case, Mah sued the police in respect of alleged torts committed by various police officers at a police lock-up. The AG, representing the police, submitted — and the court agreed — that there was a public interest in withholding certain CCTV footage of certain areas in the lock-up due to “security risks” (at [99]). Yet the court ordered that that footage be disclosed to Mah, though in the following limited manner: Mah would not be able to take copies of the footage, but instead would be allowed to view the footage at the police station (at [104]). Note that the court did consider alternative possible safeguards, such as blurring out certain parts of the footage (at [100]-[101]).
The Attorney-General may intervene in civil proceedings to assert public interest privilege: ARW v Comptroller of Income Tax [2019] 1 SLR 499 (CA), cited in Mah at [56]ff.
Leave a Reply