Benjamin Ong's notes

Notes about Singapore public law, etc. for my students (and possibly others)

Should it be compulsory for opposition MPs to be present when Parliament sits?

Someone asked: what if no opposition MP turns up to Parliament? Would that make Parliament’s decisions less democratically legitimate?

My response:

There comes a point when certain matters are left up to the political process. In your situation, the law would already have taken a step toward protecting democracy, namely, giving opposition MPs (/NCMPs/NMPs) the opportunity to be there. The law does not go further and require them to be there; they are at liberty to be there or not to be there, and to suffer the political consequences accordingly. Indeed, if the law were that certain/all MPs must turn up or be punished, I can imagine that very few people would want to be an MP; and if the law were that MPs may turn up, but that Parliamentary proceedings cannot proceed without a certain number of MPs from a certain party, then those MPs from that party could effectively hold Parliament to ransom by threatening to simply refuse to turn up.

Something similar can be said of the fact that there is no law requiring that there be any opposition MPs at all, or that someone contest every seat. The law has already done enough to uphold democracy by creating the condition under which people have the opportunity to stand in elections.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *