Benjamin Ong's notes

Notes about Singapore public law, etc. for my students (and possibly others)

How were NCMPs selected following the 2020 general election?

[I wrote this note in response to someone who asked about who the NCMPs would be following the 2020 general election. I hope it makes some of the statutory provisions clearer.]

The total number of NCMPs is 12 minus the total number of elected opposition MPs. So there will be 2 NCMPs. (section 52(1))

 How are they chosen? First, candidates who 

  1.  did not manage to get elected (section 52(2))
  2. are not from the political party that forms the Government (i.e. the PAP) (section 52(2))
  3. got at least 15% of the votes in the division (section 52(3A)(a))

are ranked according to the percentage of votes they received (section 52(2)). In the case of a group candidates in a GRC, the ‘percentage of votes’ for each individual candidate is taken to be the percentage of votes received by the group (section 52(3D)).

According to this system, the top 5 who qualify to be NCMP are:

  • KHOO POH TIONG JEFFREY (PSP): 48.31%
  • LEONG MUN WAI (PSP): 48.31%
  • N. LOGANATHAN (PSP): 48.31%
  • HAZEL POA (PSP): 48.31%
  • TAN CHENG BOCK (PSP): 48.31%

They are tied. How is the tie to be broken and 2 chosen from the 5? Since they all come from the same group, the Returning Officer must tell the group, who then have 7 days to select 2 of themselves to be NCMPs. This is because of section 52(3B)(a). 

It would be different if there were more than 2 NCMP seats up for grabs. In that case, we would have to consider the rule that not more than 2 NCMPs can be drawn from the same group of candidates in a GRC (section 52(3A)(c)). This does not apply.

You mentioned section 52(3A)(c). In effect, that says that, in the case of a constituency “that is not a group representation constituency” (i.e. an SMC), no more than 1 of the candidates from that constituency can be NCMP. This does not apply to our present situation. It would apply in the following hypothetical situation: Imagine that, in an SMC, there are 3 candidates: one from PAP, one from Party X, and one from Party Y. The PAP candidate wins. According to the ranking system described above, the Party X candidate ranks first and the Party Y candidate ranks second. In this case, the Party X candidate would become an NCMP; and section 52(3A)(c) would prevent the Party Y candidate from becoming an NCMP. 

My understanding is confirmed by the speech of Mr K Shanmugam, Minister for Law, in introducing in Parliament certain amendments to the NCMP scheme in 2010 (see https://sprs.parl.gov.sg/search/topic?reportid=019_20100427_S0004_T0012 At column 233). He said that the amendments would have the following effect: “There will also be a cap of two NCMPs coming from any one Group Representation Constituency (GRC), and a cap of one from any Single Member Constituency (SMC). This will spread out the NCMPs more evenly and make them more representative of voters who had voted for the Opposition nationwide in the General Election. In addition, the cap on NCMPs coming from a GRC will clearly distinguish between the winning and losing teams in a GRC.” (emphasis added)

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *