Benjamin Ong's notes

Notes about Singapore public law, etc. for my students (and possibly others)

The concept of the burden of proof

I feel I should say something about the meaning of “burden of proof”, “legal burden”, and “evidential burden”. Let us take as our starting point Britestone Pte Ltd v Smith & Associates Far East, Ltd [2007] 4 SLR(R) 855 (CA) at [60]:

“… at the start of the plaintiff’s case, the legal burden of proving the existence of any relevant fact that the plaintiff must prove and the evidential burden of adducing some (not inherently incredible) evidence of the existence of such fact coincide. Upon adduction of that evidence, the evidential burden shifts to the defendant, as the case may be, to adduce some evidence in rebuttal. If no evidence in rebuttal is adduced, the court may conclude from the evidence of the plaintiff that the legal burden is also discharged and making a finding on the fact against the defendant. If, on the other hand, evidence in rebuttal is adduced, the evidential burden shifts back to the plaintiff. If, ultimately, the evidential burden comes to rest on the defendant, the legal burden of proof of that relevant fact would have been discharged by the plaintiff.”

Now, let me try to explain this in simpler terms.

The “legal burden of proof” — or, for short, the “burden of proof” — means “the obligation to persuade the trier of fact that, in view of the evidence, the fact in dispute exists”: Britestone at [58]. For example, if I sue you for breach of contract, I bear the legal burden of proving that the contract exists; that you breached it; and that your breach caused me loss. If I fail to prove all of these facts, then my claim must fail, for I have failed to discharge my burden of proof. Similarly, if the Public Prosecutor prosecutes me for theft under s 378 of the Penal Code, it bears the legal burden of proving that I moved property which was in the possession of someone else; that I moved it with the intention of taking it dishonestly out of that person’s possession; and that I moved it in order to effect the taking. If the Public Prosecutor fails to prove all of those facts, then he has failed to discharge his burden of proof, I must be acquitted.

When I bear the “evidential burden of proof” (also known as the “tactical burden”), this means that my “failure to adduce some evidence, whether in propounding or rebutting, will mean a failure to engage the question of the existence of a particular fact or to keep this question alive” (Britestone at [58]). Suppose that my opponent bears the legal burden of proof. Suppose further that my opponent has adduced evidence which would lead the court to conclude in his favour. In that case, if I fail to rebut that evidence, then my opponent must succeed. In that case, one would say that, in the light of my opponent’s evidence, I bear the “evidential burden” of rebutting that evidence.

Let me illustrate this with an example. Suppose I am being prosecuted for voluntarily causing hurt, which is an offence under s 321 of the Penal Code. The Prosecution bears the legal burden of proving that I had the “intention of… causing hurt to any person”. Suppose the Prosecution adduces evidence that I make eye contact with someone, shout loudly, and then punch that person. Does this evidence, in and of itself, prove conclusively that I intended to cause hurt? Maybe; maybe not. But it does not matter. The point is that, as a matter of common sense, a person who has seen such evidence, is likely to think that I had the intention to cause hurt. In that case, the evidential burden is on me to rebut that evidence. If I do not, then the judge — like any reasonable person with common sense — would naturally conclude that I did have the intention to cause hurt.

It is in this light that we must understand passages such as the following extract from the CA’s judgment in Ridzuan (at [51]):

“an applicant who alleges that the PP’s decision declining to grant him a certificate of substantive assistance was made in breach of Art 12 of the Constitution would satisfy the evidentiary burden he bears if he can show two things – first, that his level of involvement in the offence and the consequent knowledge he acquired of the drug syndicate he was dealing with was practically identical to a co-offender’s level of involvement and the knowledge the co-offender could have acquired, and second, and more importantly, that he and his co-offender had provided practically the same information to CNB – yet only his co-offender had been given the certificate of substantive assistance. This follows from our holding at [40]–[43] above that the applicant does not have to produce evidence directly impugning the process by which the PP reached his decision; instead, he can discharge the evidentiary burden he bears by highlighting circumstances that raise a prima facie case of reasonable suspicion of breach of the relevant standard. The situation we described earlier in this paragraph, if it were to occur, will raise questions as to why only one co-offender and not the other was granted the certificate of substantive assistance.”

This does not mean that the application for judicial review will succeed if the applicant shows one of the “two things”. All it means is that, if the applicant shows one of the “two things”, he thereby “raise[s] questions” such that, if the applicant’s arguments are not rebutted, then the applicant will succeed. In other words, the evidential burden of proof shifts to the respondent. However, it is still open to the respondent to rebut the applicant’s arguments; if the respondent successfully rebuts them, then the evidential burden shifts back to the applicant, in that, if the applicant does not rebut the respondent’s rebuttal, then the respondent will succeed (i.e. the applicant’s application for judicial review will fail). In short, even if A has raised enough evidence to shift the evidentiary burden to B, that does not mean that A will ultimately be victorious, because it is still open to B to rebut A’s evidence, and A to rebut B’s rebuttal, and B to rebut A’s rebuttal of B’s rebuttal, etc.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *