The question asked whether “recent developments in the political arena in Singapore” have rendered the Presidency “now irrelevant”. It was insufficient only to discuss the “recent developments in the political arena”, or to argue that the Presidency is “irrelevant”, without discussing whether there is a link between the two.
Given the reference in the question to “a different era in Singapore’s constitutional and political history”, it would have been useful to discuss the particular “recent developments in the political arena” that have marked a change from the past “different era”.
It was necessary to distinguish between arguments that the (popularly) elected Presidency was “irrelevant”, and arguments that the Presidency itself was “irrelevant”. Strong answers discussed the potential “irrelevan[ce]” of the President’s functions separately from the potential “irrelevan[ce]” of the fact that the President is popular elected.
Students were welcome to examine the connotations of “relic” and “era”, and hence challenge the assumption that the time at which the elected Presidency was so long ago – and so alien to the present – that it could be said to fall within a different “era” from the present. Students were also welcome to argue that the statement that the elected Presidency is “now irrelevant” implies that it was once relevant, and to challenge the truth of this implication.
In weaker essays, the only “recent developments” discussed were developments relating to the Presidency itself. These essays sometimes stopped at asserting that, given these developments, the Presidency cannot be said to be “irrelevant”. The weakness in this approach was this: if the changes prevent the Presidency from becoming “irrelevant”, then there must have been something that would, but for the changes, have made the Presidency “irrelevant”, and so an account of the changes would have been incomplete without an account of this something.
Certain weaker essays criticised the institution of the elected Presidency but fell short of showing that these criticisms rendered the elected Presidency irrelevant.
Some essays asserted that, because certain risks against which the Presidency is meant to guard have not recently eventuated, the Presidency is irrelevant. However, one may ask: is the point of checks and balances not to guard against the possibility of risks eventuating?
It is not true that the President is the only check against the risk of the legislature frittering away public funds. At the same time, it is not true that the Presidency must be “irrelevant” because it is possible for people to vote out a spendthrift government: is Singapore to tolerate profligacy for up to five years?
Leave a Reply