Benjamin Ong's notes

Notes about Singapore public law, etc. for my students (and possibly others)

Mayors in Singapore

Someone asked what Mayors in Singapore do, and whether they are redundant.

To answer this question, it would be useful to start with the law stating what Mayors’ functions are. That law isn’t found in the Constitution. Instead, a search on Singapore Statutes Online leads us to the People’s Association (Community Development Councils) Rules. Rule 6(1) tells us: “The Board may designate the Chairman of the Council for a District to be the Mayor of that District where… the number of residents in the District is not less than 150,000.”

So we next need to find out what the “Board”, a “Council” for a “District”, and the “Chairman” of the “Council” are. When we read rules 2 to 5, we find out that the word “Council” refers a Community Development Council, which may be appointed by the Board of Management of the People’s Association for a certain area in Singapore (called a “District”). Rule 3 tells us that all this may take place “[f]or the purposes of carrying out the objects of the Association… and the activities advantageous towards, or necessary or convenient for, the furtherance of such objects”.

So the last piece of the puzzle is: what are the “objects of the Association”? We are told in section 8 of the People’s Association Act 1960. Those, in turn, are the functions of Community Development Councils, whose chairpersons may be given the title of “Mayor”. 

So the question of whether Mayors are redundant is, essentially, the question of whether the functions of the People’s Association are the same as the functions of MPs. They are not, although they overlap. To be sure, there are conversations to be had about whether Mayors do effectively perform their functions, and indeed whether they should have those functions in the first place. But that question is different from the question of whether all of their functions are performed by someone else — which they are not.

It is also worth considering what resources Community Development Councils have to perform those functions, compared to individual MPs. Take, for example, “the fostering of community bonding and strengthening of social cohesion among the people of Singapore”. It is likely that CDCs have more funds to (for example) organise events for this purpose than individual MPs do.

Finally, it is worth considering that elected MPs are elected whereas CDCs, including their Mayors, are not. (Some of them happen to be elected MPs, but they were not elected as Mayors.) That means that elected MPs face the threat of being voted out. That, in turn, keeps them on their toes, and ensures that they effectively perform important functions such as acting as the bridge between individuals and the Government — functions which the People’s Association doesn’t serve.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *