Benjamin Ong's notes

Notes about Singapore public law, etc. for my students (and possibly others)

Oral vs. written advocacy in Singapore

See Re Lord Goldsmith Peter Henry PC QC [2013] 4 SLR 921. At [29]-[31] (emphasis removed) the High Court remarked: 

“the appellate process in the Singapore Court of Appeal has evolved to be more writing-centred than that in many other common law court systems. The written medium occupies a central role in the appellate process here […] 

Court rules require the parties to make detailed written submissions in the form of Cases prior to the hearing of oral arguments. The Case is a formal document that must provide structured and comprehensive arguments. It affords counsel a platform to make rational, dispassionate and intellectual submissions on the merits of their cause and the finer points of law that are in play. In short, the parties are expected to place on record their entire panoply of submissions through the written medium well in advance of the appeal hearing […] 

Oral arguments therefore ordinarily serve as a useful concluding supplement to the Case. During the oral phase, counsel are expected to present the essence of their Case. Counsel also assumes the role of assisting the court to clarify information that could give a clearer picture of the issues rather than functioning as traditional orators who have an expectation that they will be heard out at length according to their desires.”

It would follow that lawyers arguing appeals must come to the courtroom prepared to answer questions from the court. By that stage, the court would have read the written arguments. Bear that in mind when considering the law on excessive judicial interference and reconciling it with what you might witness when you watch the hearing of an appeal.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *