Section 121(2) gives the Minister for Transport the power to make subsidiary legislation, known as “rules”, “with respect to the precedence of vehicles and pedestrians respectively and generally with respect to the movement of traffic (including pedestrians) at and in the vicinity of crossings”. Section 121(3) gives us examples of such rules: for example, the Minister may make rules “prohibiting pedestrian traffic on the carriageway within 100 metres of a crossing”.
Please note what section 121(3) does. It does not say that pedestrians may not cross within 100 metres of a crossing (other than at the crossing itself). Indeed, it is not directed at pedestrians at all. Rather, it is directed at the Minister. The purpose of sections 121(2)-(3) is simply to give the Minister the power to make certain subsidiary legislation for certain purposes.
The Minister, exercising this power, made rule 3(1) of the Road Traffic (Pedestrian Crossings) Rules, which prohibits “any pedestrian, cyclist, mobility vehicle user or PMD rider” from crossing the road within 50 metres of a crossing (other than at the crossing itself).
There is no contradiction between the two. The Act gives the Minister the power to make rules prohibiting crossing within 100 metres of a crossing. The Minister exercised that power, but not to the maximum possible extent: he only made a rule prohibiting crossing within 50 metres of a crossing. That is lawful. Just because the Act gave him a power doesn’t mean that he has to exercise that power to the fullest possible extent.
You may also ask: didn’t the Act only give the Minister the power to make rules relating to “pedestrian traffic”? Does rule 3(1) of the Rules exceed these powers, by applying not only to pedestrians but also “any… cyclist, mobility vehicle user or PMD rider”?
The answer is no. Section 121(2) of the Act gives the Minister a general power to “make rules… generally with respect to the movement of traffic (including pedestrians) at and in the vicinity of crossings”. This is a wide power, and it clearly allows the Minister to make rule 3(1) of the Rules. Section 121(3) gives us examples of types of rules that the Minister may make using this power, e.g. rules relating to pedestrians near crossings. They are just examples. We know they are just examples because of the words “Without limiting subsection (2)” — in other words, the examples in section 121(3) do not limit the general power to make rules in section 121(2).
Leave a Reply