Benjamin Ong's notes

Notes about Singapore public law, etc. for my students (and possibly others)

Feedback on a student presentation about modern slavery

As [one team of students] pointed out, ‘traditional’ slavery means human beings being treated as property. Modern slavery, then, shares certain features in common with ‘traditional’ slavery, but what? Perhaps the following might be food for thought – I’m no historian, but the following is what I remember from when I was a student:

  • In Roman law, there was a distinction between ‘persons’ and ‘things’: ‘persons’ have legal rights and duties, whereas ‘things’ are the object of legal rights and duties. Slaves were ‘things’, not ‘persons’.
  • This had several legal consequences. For example, a slave could not own property, because property ownership is a kind of right, and only ‘persons’ can own ‘things’; a ‘thing’ can’t own another ‘thing’. A slave might have been allowed to have some personal possessions (including being paid), but that was only because the ‘owner’ of the slave allowed it; the slave had no legal right to those things. If you killed a slave, the ‘owner’ could sue you for causing property damage.
  • The defining feature of slavery was not quite (a) doing menial work or (b) being treated badly. In ancient Rome, a doctor or an accountant could have been a slave. They could have been treated well. But they did not have the right to be treated well. What they had, they had (for the most part) because of the beneficence of their ‘owners’ and not because they had a legal right to it. (That said, I should point out that I do not know what proportion of slaves did what kind of work, how they were treated, how much they were paid, etc. I suppose it would be fascinating to study the interplay between the law of slavery and the socio-economic forces determining how slaves were treated in practice – but that’s for another day.)
  • One right that slaves lacked was autonomy. That said, slavery was not the only form of legal status that took away a person’s autonomy. Consider the system of feudalism in operation in (at least) England. Nowadays, there are comparatively few landowners; often, people rent land (and/or buildings) from the owners (‘landlords’) in exchange for money. But under feudalism, the landlord was more literally a lord, with not only economic but also legal power, including the power to make rules governing the manor. As a tenant, you did not simply pay money; you had to perform certain services, such as performing military service for the lord, paying the lord in the form of grain, etc. You could pay for these things – say, hire someone to do the military service, or buy grain from someone else – but the fact remained that you were liable to do these things.
  • Moreover, there wasn’t just one owner and one tenant; there could be a whole chain of ownership, with the king/queen owning all the land in England; lords below that; and so on… with serfs right at the bottom. Serfs were especially un-free; in fact, “unfree” was the technical term to describe them. Not only were they obliged to do certain things (like pretty much everyone else – even lords were subordinate to the king/queen); they didn’t even have a fixed job.

Of course, modern slavery need not have all the features of traditional slavery or serfdom – otherwise, we would just call it “slavery” or “serfdom”. That said, merely working for someone isn’t slavery/serfdom; neither is merely doing unpleasant work. If you asked me to boil slavery/serfdom to just one point, it would be a lack of control over one’s life.

Of course, there can be degrees of lack of control. If, for example, someone forces you to work by threatening to kill you if you don’t, we would have no hesitation in saying that you have no choice. But suppose that person threatens to, say, make it harder for you to purchase food, or restrict your movement? Suppose that if you don’t work then you won’t have a home/food – would that count as slavery? Would it matter if the threat of homelessness/hunger/etc. isn’t imposed deliberately by one person, but is instead the product of a combination of socio-economic circumstances?

As both teams rightly pointed out, there can be a law about something without using a certain term for that thing. But, as we have seen earlier in the course, and as both teams reminded us, labels can matter. The word “slavery” has certain connotations that no other word has. Also, by framing the problem as one of “modern slavery” rather than multiple problems of trafficking, forced labour, etc., we prevent thinking in silos. On the other hand, one potential problem with focusing on “modern slavery” is that, by focusing our attention on the worst/most egregious/most obvious situations that are akin to slavery, we may lose sight of other situations that are less egregious but still bad, more subtle or obscure, etc.

It’s possible for a law to target something without explicitly outlawing that thing. For example, some of the mandatory conditions attached to work passes under the Employment of Foreign Manpower Act might have the effect of making modern slavery easy to detect, reducing the likelihood of conditions in which exploitation can occur, etc. […] Even a requirement that workers have time off work can help, in that it can be an opportunity for the worker to seek help if they are being exploited. (I do acknowledge the point that it can be difficult to detect breaches of the requirement that employers give workers time off work, but there are some solutions, e.g. surprise inspections including interviews with the worker in the absence of the employer – which I believe MOM sometimes does, at least for migrant domestic workers.)

I appreciate [one team’s] pointing out the role of NGOs – we shouldn’t forget the role that they can play in governance. This was a good example of how one can go into more detail than stopping at saying that the government ‘should do more’, etc. […] If there had been more time, it would have been good for both teams to say a little more about what precisely the Anti-Slavery Commissions in the UK/Australia/etc. do, and whether they have improved things. The Commissions might, for example, organise campaigns, but one may ask: didn’t campaigns exist before that too?

That said, while labels matter, they aren’t the only thing that matters. For example, while there isn’t a body named ‘Anti-Slavery Commission’ in Singapore, there are various bodies that do some of the things that the Commissions in the UK/Australia do – consider, for example, the MOM’s ACE Group? (I’m not saying that their work is perfect; I’m just saying that if you want to draw a comparison, they are the entities in Singapore which you may want to consider drawing comparisons with.)

Sometimes, we talk about the need for those in power to take into account the needs, views, etc. of people. But some people may have difficulties making themselves heard – whether because of systemic issues or other reasons – and NGOs can help in that regard.

Note that it’s possible for a country to do what some international treaty requires, without necessarily signing up to that treaty.

There are laws requiring that certain commercial entities report certain matters; don’t confuse this requirement with an obligation to investigate:

  • Section 54(4) of the UK’s Act requires each such entity to report “the steps the organisation has taken during the financial year to ensure that slavery and human trafficking is not taking place — (i) in any of its supply chains, and (ii) in any part of its own business”, or to issue “a statement that the organisation has taken no such steps”. This is not an obligation to investigate anything.
  • Similarly, in Australia, certain entities have to “describe the risks of modern slavery practices in the operations and supply chains of the reporting entity” and “describe the actions taken by the reporting entity and any entity that the reporting entity owns or controls, to assess and address those risks, including due diligence and remediation processes” (Modern Slavery Act 2018 (Cth), section 16), but this appears to me to stop short of an obligation to take any particular action to address the risks.
  • Besides, there is the question of what the consequences of non-compliance with reporting requirements are, which in turn may have an impact on the rate of non-compliance (which the Wednesday team discussed). It might have been useful to present some examples of reports by businesses and comment on how useful they are.

One team referred to the finding by Research Across Borders that 60% of domestic workers are “exploited”. As with all statistics, we must consider the methodology, as did the MOM in its response. I don’t have the time to consider this point in greater detail, but I would add this: The “60%” figure, taken in isolation, might be of limited usefulness, if only because it purports to encompass multiple types of “exploitation” – which may well be solved in different ways. Even taking the Research Across Borders report at face value, I would suggest that more specific findings – for example, the rate of late salary payment – might be more useful.

One last point – [one student] asked a very interesting question: what if certain acts of exploitation take place overseas? Can Singapore law do nothing? The answer is not necessarily no. For one thing, as a matter of international law, it is generally accepted that States are entitled to regulate not only conduct within their territories, but also conduct of their nationals anywhere in the world. (See, for example, section 376C of the Penal Code 1871.) Also, even if a contract is entered into overseas, that doesn’t mean that the Singapore courts don’t have the jurisdiction to hear and decide disputes involving that contract – there’s a complicated series of rules, which form part of the body of law known as “private international law” or “the conflict of laws”. (Relevant factors include where the parties/witnesses are, and where the contract is to be performed – which itself depends on the precise content of the contract.)

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *