In class, someone raised the point that laws respond to the needs of society. I responded that I could think of at least one example of a law for which, to use a colloquial turn of phrase, nobody asked.
What I had in mind was s 12A of the Registration of Births and Deaths Act 1937, which allows the Registrar-General of Births and Deaths to “refuse the entry or alteration of a child’s name in a register of births under this Act” on various grounds. These include situations when the name is “obscene or offensive” or “contrary to the public interest”.
This provision was introduced by the National Registration (Amendment) Bill 2016. During debates on Parliament on that Bill, Mr Leon Perera asked: “Since every act of legislation should be a response to a real-world problem or a problem that is likely to happen, my question is: have there been a significant or an increasing number of persons wanting to register their names that might be deemed to contain an impermissible reference to a rank or an award or deemed to be offensive or contrary to the national interest?”
Mr Desmond Lee, who had introduced the Bill, gave examples of names that the Registrar-General would have the power to refuse to enter onto the register: “Those that used titles like ‘Sir’, ‘Professor’, ‘President’; names that are offensive or that use expletives. One other example could be names that could possibly be deemed derogatory or highly offensive to any particular race or religion.”
Speaking for myself, I can see the force in allowing the prohibition of a name such as “Shit” or “F*** You”, notwithstanding the public interest in the freedom to choose one’s child’s name. I can also see the force in allowing the Registrar-General to prohibit someone from naming their child “Adolf Hitler” (a name which some listicles I found online say is prohibited in, among other places, Malaysia, though I have yet to find an independent source).
That said, I do note that Mr Lee didn’t squarely address Mr Perera’s question of why the Government saw fit to introduce the Bill that would insert s 12A. I am driven to the conclusion that this is a law for which ‘nobody asked’. That does not mean that the law is useless; I, for one, would not want someone to be named “Little Bobby Tables” (I hesitate to type the full form of his name here.*) The fact remains, however, that it is not clear what, if anything, the law was introduced in response to.
In the coming weeks, we’ll be studying what one can do in the event that one wishes to challenge the Registrar’s decision to refuse to enter a name in the register.
* If you don’t get that joke, but you want to, let me know, or, better yet, ask someone who is actually qualified to answer well. Don’t worry; it’s not in our syllabus.
Leave a Reply