The terms “anxious scrutiny”, “light touch”, “super-Wednesbury”, and “sub-Wednesbury” are not terms of art in Singaporean case law. It is not wrong to use them, but there is the risk that a court will not know what you are talking about when you use them.
Moreover, for the sake of conceptual clarity, it is often better to explain exactly what these entail — for example:
- “higher threshold which the applicant has to cross to make out unreasonableness”
- “court suggested that [constitutional right] was a consideration which the decision-maker was bound to take into account: Vijaya Kumar“
- “the decision-maker failed to take into account relevant evidence: Fong Thin Choo. The court can quash a decision if there is “manifestly insufficient evidence”: Axis Law v IPOS. As the applicant’s [fundamental right] is at stake, the court ought to be less easily satisfied that the evidence justifying [decision] is satisfied, as in Bugdaycay…”
- “because national security is at stake, the court will not readily hold that the decision is irrational; however, the question remains whether the decision is ultra vires the statute, just as in Tan Seet Eng…”
- “even accepting that the proportionality of the decision is non-justiciable, the court may still inquire into its rationality, as in Colin Chan v MITA“
- “while the court cannot inquire into what national security requires, it can and must inquire into whether the decision is based on national security considerations (Chng Suan Tze at [93])”
To reduce all of these possibilities down to just one or two words would not do justice to the wide variety of methods by which the law controls state action, as well as the doctrinal differences between them. It would also not be the most persuasive if these one or two words are not part of Singapore law.
Leave a Reply