An ouster clause is a statutory provision that purports to prevent the courts from performing judicial review — or, as one might say, to oust the courts’ power of judicial review. Here are some examples of ouster clauses:
- “any decision of a claim or question [by some executive officer] shall be final”
- “The determination by [some executive officer] of any application made to them under this Act shall not be called in question in any court of law.”
- “determinations, awards and other decisions of the Tribunal… shall not be subject to appeal or be liable to be questioned in any court”
- “… the decision of the Minister shall be final and not open to review or challenge on any ground whatsoever.”
We have discussed at length the importance of judicial review of executive action. Therefore, the courts often omit to give effect to ouster clauses, and therefore hold that they can perform judicial review of the executive action in question. How, you ask, can they do so without being said to be acting in defiance of the law? There are, broadly speaking, two techniques:
- A court can hold that the provision, properly interpreted, doesn’t actually have the effect of ousting judicial review. For example, a court may hold that the word “decision” only refers to lawfully-made decisions and not unlawful ones.
- A court can hold that the provision is unconstitutional. The Singapore courts have not yet explicitly said such a thing, but it is likely that they will. In Nagaenthran a/l K Dharmalingam v Public Prosecutor [2019] 2 SLR 216 at [74], the Court of Appeal described an ouster clause as being “constitutionally suspect for being in violation of Art 93 of the Singapore Constitution as well as the principle of the separation of powers”. I attempted to unpack this argument in Benjamin Joshua Ong, ‘The constitutionality of ouster clauses’ (2019) 19 Oxford University Commonwealth Law Journal 157 <https://ink.library.smu.edu.sg/sol_research/2915/>. In short:
- Article 93 says that the Supreme Court (part of which is the High Court) have judicial power. The power to perform judicial review is, by definition (through conventional usage), part of the High Court’s judicial power. (Tan Seet Eng at [1] says so: “Judges are entrusted with the task of ensuring that any exercise of state power is done within legal limits.”) So an ouster clause would stop the High Court from exercising the judicial power that the High Court, by definition, has.
- If some authority’s decisions are immune from judicial review, then they have the final power to determine what their legal limits are. If someone has the final power to determine what their legal limits are, then they, in effect, exercise judicial power. In other words, if a statutory provision prevents judicial review of some executive authority’s decision, then its effect is to confer judicial power on that executive authority. That would run contrary to Article 93, which, properly interpreted, vests judicial power exclusively in the courts — for an executive authority is not a court.
Now, it may be that a statutory provision makes the legal limits to some executive body’s powers very wide. But, however wide the powers are, it is the court’s job to ensure that their limits are not transgressed.
Leave a Reply