I would like to point out the following extracts from Bijoe Emannuel v State of Kerala AIR 1986 Ker 32 <https://indiankanoon.org/doc/1657841/> (in which the High Court of Kerala dismissed a challenge by Jehovah’s Witnesses to a rule requiring students to sing the national anthem), which bear some similarity to certain passages from Colin Chan v PP:
“By the Constitution (42nd Amendment) Act, 1976 the Preamble to the Constitution was amended and the words “socialist secular” have been inserted and the word “integrity” has been incorporated after the word ‘unity’. By the same Amendment Act, Part IV-A containing Article 51A was newly added under the caption ‘Fundamental Duties’.
These provisions would show that the Parliament was more concerned about the unity and integrity of India. By the introduction of the aforesaid changes in the Constitution I am of the view, that the Parliament has reasserted that it is the fundamental duty of every citizen to strive hard to uphold and protect the sovereignty, unity and integrity of our motherland. All such rights, fundamental or otherwise must therefore subserve the sovereignty, integrity and unity of this great nation.” (emphasis added)
and, later:
“As observed by the Supreme Court in Swamiar’s case (AIR 1954 SC 282)… [f]reedom of religion guaranteed under our Constitution… is not absolute to be exercised independently of the Fundamental Duty prescribed by the same organic instrument. In short, the religious beliefs, must reconcile with the right of a State to employ the sovereign power to ensure orderly living ‘without which constitutional guarantees of civil liberties would be a mockery’… The conduct of the members of Jehovah’s Witnesses in not showing unqualified respect to Constitution, the National Anthem etc. would endanger the security of the Nation in that the same will develop, among the citizens a tendency to ignore the mandates of the Constitution thereby defeating the object discernible from the Preamble and other provisions of the Constitution, to accomplish which, the people gave the Constitution to themselves. It therefore follows that if religious practices based on religious faith and belief protected by the State, run counter to public order, morality, health or a policy of the Government to uphold the sovereignty, integrity and unity of the nation or social welfare embarked upon, then the said religious practice must give way for the benefit of the people and the nation as a whole.” (emphasis added)
Note that Article 51A(c) of the Constitution of India has stated, as of 1976: “It shall be the duty of every citizen of India — to uphold and protect the sovereignty, unity and integrity of India”.
And Article 25(1) states: “Subject to public order, morality and health and to the other provisions of this Part, all persons are equally entitled to freedom of conscience and the right freely to profess, practise and propagate religion.” (“[T]his Part” refers to Part III of the Constitution, which pertains to “fundamental rights”.)
Please note that the decision of the High Court of Kerala was overruled by the Supreme Court of India: AIR 1987 SC 748 <https://indiankanoon.org/doc/1508089/>.
Leave a Reply