Benjamin Ong's notes

Notes about Singapore public law, etc. for my students (and possibly others)

Freedom to practise religion: the “essential practices” test

The history of the ‘essential practices’ test has been usefully set out by Gautam Bhatia in this blog post: https://indconlawphil.wordpress.com/2015/08/19/essential-religious-practices-and-the-rajasthan-high-courts-santhara-judgment-tracking-the-history-of-a-phrase/. (He builds on these ideas in his article in Global Constitutionalism: https://search-proquest-com.libproxy.smu.edu.sg/docview/1835779220/fulltextPDF/10B42EC62EE9428FPQ/1?accountid=28662) 

Bhatia traces the “essential practices” test to the following statement by B R Ambedkar in India’s Constituent Assembly in 1948: 

“The religious conceptions in this country are so vast that they cover every aspect of life, from birth to death. There is nothing which is not religion and if personal law is to be saved, I am sure about it that in social matters we will come to a standstill. I do not think it is possible to accept a position of that sort. There is nothing extraordinary in saying that we ought to strive hereafter to limit the definition of religion in such a manner that we shall not extend beyond beliefs and such rituals as may be connected with ceremonials which are essentially religious. It is not necessary that the sort of laws, for instance, laws relating to tenancy or laws relating to succession, should be governed by religion.”

Bhatia continues:

“Ambedkar’s use of the term ‘essentially religious’, therefore, was in response to a very specific concern. He was worried that unlike in the West, with its seemingly clear demarcation between the City of God and the City of Man, there was no aspect of Indian life which was untouched by religion. Consequently, insofar as the Constitution protected religion and personal laws, there was a very real risk that it would entirely hamstring the State’s power to pass social legislation. He was, therefore, adamant that there must be a separation between religious activities, and secular activities tinged with religion. The latter could have no constitutional immunity from legislation. In Ambedkar’s formulation, it is clear the word ‘essentially’ qualified ‘religious’, and was designed to separate the religious from the secular.”

I could go on quoting from the blog post, but I may as well ask those of you who are interested to read it in its entirety.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *