In class [that is, a class for students other than LLB students], when someone asked this question, I struggled a bit to summarise the relevant parts of the law on charities, which can be somewhat arcane. I just checked a couple of textbooks, and concluded that the law is even more arcane than I remember. So the best answer I can give, without using too much legal jargon, is this:
The AG is a guardian of the public interest. Charities are supposed to exist for various aims relating to the public interest. Therefore, the AG may act in the interests of a charitable cause or the beneficiaries of a charity. For example, at common law, if a charity misapplies its funds, the AG can sue to stop this. (One would think that it is the supposed beneficiaries of the charity who should have the right to sue the charity. But the beneficiaries are often not in a position to do so – they may lack the means, etc. Besides, there may not be clearly identifiable human beneficiaries in the first place, e.g. in the case of a charitable trust that exists to advance a certain religion.)
The common law of charities in Singapore has been modified by the Charities Act 1994. Nonetheless, the Attorney-General has certain functions under that Act. For example, under s 23 of that Act, if the Commissioner of Charities, having begun an inquiry into a charity, is satisfied that “there is or has been any misconduct or mismanagement in the administration of the charity” and that it is “necessary or desirable to act for the purpose of protecting the property of the charity or securing a proper application for the purposes of the charity of that property or of property coming to the charity”, then the Commissioner may do various things, such as removing a member of the charity’s governing board – but the Commissioner can only do this with the Attorney-General’s consent. This took place in 2013: see https://www.agc.gov.sg/docs/default-source/newsroom-doucments/media-releases/2013/agc-statement_ag’s-role-under-the-charities-act_approved_11-april-2013.pdf
Another example of the AG’s role with regard to charities is Re Lot 114-69 Mukim 22, Singapore. In 1920, Lim Kit Fah sold a piece of land to five people jointly, including Ong Choo Kee. Some time after Ong Choo Kee died, his grandson, Ong Yew Kew, applied to court for a declaration that he (and not the other people to whom Lim Kit Fah had sold the land) had become the owner of the land outright. The Attorney-General objected, arguing that Lim Kit Fah had intended the land to be used for charitable purposes (namely, the advancement of religion); therefore, Ong Yew Kew could not own the land outright, but was bound to continue those charitable purposes.
The High Court initially concluded that the Ong family had occupied the land for so long, and the public charitable purpose had fallen into disuse for so long, that Ong Yew Kew was entitled to take over the land ([2001] 1 SLR(R) 811). However, on hearing further evidence, the High Court decided ([2003] 1 SLR(R) 773) that the land charitable purpose had not fallen into disuse: while the Ong family had lived on the land, the temple on the land had remained open to the public. (By the way, if I’m not mistaken, the temple in question is this one: https://kewongyah.org.sg/en/#section1)
Leave a Reply