Benjamin Ong's notes

Notes about Singapore public law, etc. for my students (and possibly others)

“[I]nsult[ing] the modesty of any woman” etc. – language matters

Section 509 of the Penal Code used to state: “Whoever, intending to insult the modesty of any woman, utters any word, makes any sound or gesture, or exhibits any object, intending that such word or sound shall be heard, or that such gesture or object shall be seen by such woman, or intrudes upon the privacy of such woman, shall be punished with imprisonment for a term which may extend to one year, or with fine, or with both.”

The courts interpreted section 509 as including all manner of things, including indecent exposure (Ramakrishnan s/o Ramayan v PP [1998] 3 SLR(R) 161), peeping at someone who was showering (Ye Wei Gen v PP [1999] 2 SLR(R) 1074), filming people using the restroom or changing (PP v Tay Beng Guan Albert [2000] 2 SLR(R) 778), and taking ‘upskirt’ photographs (PP v Ng Jiak Teng [2007] SGDC 115).

In 2019, the Criminal Law Reform Act replaced s 509 of the Penal Code with section 377BA. This was worded identically, except that “woman” was changed to “person”. Also, various provisions on sexual offences were added to the Penal Code, including ones specifically criminalising voyeurism (section 377BB-377BE), “sexual exposure” (including ‘cyber-flashing’) (section 377BF), and “child abuse material” (sections 377BG-377BL).

Is it a crime to possess an “intimate image” etc. taken without the subject’s consent, if someone sent it to you without your having asked for it? What about if a child takes a nude picture of themselves? See sections 377BM-377BN.

 I think the 2019 changes can only be a good thing. Whatever “modesty” means, it would be wrong to assume that only women have it. And the new provisions comprehensively cover new forms of sexual offences, not all of which might have been covered by the old law.

But let’s dig a bit deeper into the language of ‘insulting modesty’. I think this opinion piece by Avantika Tewari explains, much more eloquently than I did in class, what the problem is: https://feminisminindia.com/2017/08/28/modesty-outraged-patriarchy-law/

I think the following extracts from the Indian Supreme Court case of Rupan Deol Bajaj v KPS Gill [1996] Cri LJ 81 show why the language is potentially problematic:

  • “Modesty” means “womanly propriety of behaviour; scrupulous chastity of thought, speech and conduct”; being “decorous in manner and conduct; not forward or lewd; shamefast”; “freedom from coarseness, indelicacy or indecency; a regard for propriety in dress, speech or conduct”; “womanly propriety of behaviour; scrupulous chastity of thought, speech and conduct (in man or woman); reserve or sense of shame proceeding from instinctive aversion to impure or coarse suggestions”.
  • This includes “any act done to or in the presence of a woman [that] is clearly suggestive of sex according to the common notions of mankind”.
  • The “ultimate test” for outrage of modesty is: whether “the action of the offender [is] such as could be perceived as one which is capable of shocking the sense of decency of a woman”.  It need not have “sexual overtones”: it was still an “affront to the normal sense of feminine decency” and to the “dignity of the lady”.

In short, the problem is that the language of ‘insulting modesty’ doesn’t accurately reflect what is wrong with (say) molesting someone or taking an ‘upskirt’ photograph. What is wrong with doing so is not that it is ‘improper’, ‘coarse’, or ‘shameful’ for the victim (if anything, it is the offender who should be ashamed!), but rather, that it is an intrusion on personal privacy, bodily integrity, etc. This being so, making the former section 509 gender-neutral did not address all of the problems.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *