Suppose you had a statute that banned women from driving, and you wanted to challenge it under Art 12(1).
You would want to persuade the court to adopt the following analysis:
A
- The differentia is between men drivers and women drivers.
- This differentia is ‘unintelligible’ in the expanded sense.
- So the statute fails the ‘intelligible differentia’ test.
But not:
B
- The differentia is between men and women.
- This differentia is ‘unintelligible’ in the expanded sense.
- So the statute fails the ‘intelligible differentia’ test.
The problem with B is that it will be much harder to show that the differentia between men and women is ‘unintelligible’ in that “no reasonable person would ever contemplate the differentia concerned as being functional as intelligible differentia” (Lim Meng Suang (CA) at [67]; emphasis in original). This is because one can think of plenty of reasons why a law might differentiate between men and women. By contrast, it is much harder to think of a reason why a law might differentiate between men drivers and women drivers, so A is more likely to succeed.
Alternatively, you could argue:
C
- The differentia is between men drivers and women drivers.
- The object is to promote social harmony.
- But there is no logical link between treating men drivers and women drivers differently, and promoting social harmony.
- So the statute fails the ‘rational nexus’ test.
But you would want to resist any attempt by the state to argue:
D
- The differentia is between men drivers and women drivers.
- The object is to prevent women from driving.
- There is a logical link between treating men drivers and women drivers differently, and preventing women from driving. (In fact, there is a complete coincidence between the differentia and the object.)
- So the statute passes the ‘rational nexus’ test.
Leave a Reply