I find the following passages from GHI v Public Prosecutor [2024] SGHC 220 noteworthy. (I must warn you that the full judgment necessarily goes into some detail about the facts of the case, in which a child had been molested.)
- At [35]: “Victims of sexual crimes cannot be straitjacketed in the expectation that they must act or react in a certain manner (GBR v Public Prosecutor and another appeal [2018] 3 SLR 1048 (“GBR”) at [20]). There is no general rule requiring victims of sexual offences to report such offences immediately or in a timely fashion. In particular, young victims of sexual assault may not report offences in a timely manner for various reasons including feelings of shame and fear. Delay in reporting is not, on its own, a reason to disbelieve a victim. The court should consider the reasons for the delay in reporting the offences to the police or to anyone else (Public Prosecutor v Mohd Ariffan bin Mohd Hassan [2019] 2 SLR 490 at [65]–[68]).”
- At [69], on questioning witnesses: “… I noted that the victim in the present case was questioned on her attire at the time of the molest. The practice of asking victims about their clothing at the time of the alleged offence is acceptable if this sheds light on how the offence was committed. For example, the line of questioning may confirm whether the touching was above or under clothes, whether there was skin-on-skin contact and/or how there came to be such skin-on-skin contact. Such questions are necessary to provide the court with the proper context in which the offence was committed. However, the enquiry becomes objectionable when it is premised on, or leads to, the submission that the victim’s attire had in some way, invited the sexual assault. For example, any line of questioning which invites the implication that the victim had encouraged unwanted attention because she was dressed provocatively, must be rejected.”
- And at [71]: “… I emphasise that the court will not tolerate a line of inquiry regarding the victim’s attire when its implication is such that the victim invited the sexual assault.”
- And again at [73]: “It should be borne in mind that the purpose of cross-examination is not to cause unnecessary discomfort to, harass or abuse a witness. In cases of sexual offences especially, unwarranted questioning of the victim’s credibility, delving into irrelevant personal history or insinuating blame can not only re-traumatise the victim but also perpetuate harmful stereotypes about sexual violence. This approach can dissuade other victims from coming forward for fear of being subjected to a similar ordeal.”
The court also quoted rule 3 of the Evidence (Restrictions on Questions and Evidence in Criminal Proceedings) Rules 2018:
“Restrictions on questions and evidence in criminal proceedings involving sexual offence or child abuse offence
3. In criminal proceedings where the accused is charged with committing a sexual offence or child abuse offence, the following apply:
(a) except with the permission of the court, no question may be asked of the alleged victim of the offence, during cross‑examination by or on behalf of the accused, about the alleged victim’s sexual behaviour or physical appearance;
(b) except with the permission of the court, no evidence may be adduced by or on behalf of the accused about the alleged victim’s sexual behaviour or physical appearance.”
In Public Prosecutor v Mohd Ariffan bin Mohd Hassan, the Court of Appeal (at [63]) accepted the expert evidence of Ms Ng Pei Yu, Vivienne, the Chief Psychologist at the Ministry of Social and Family Development, and decided as follows. (Again, the full judgment sets out the details of a case in which a young person was sexually assaulted.)
“63 In relation to the issue of delay in reporting, we accept the expert opinion of Ms Ng, which was undisputed by the respondent, that only a small proportion of victims of sexual offences report the offences in a timely manner. Ms Ng stated in her expert report that:
5.3.4 Very few victims report immediately to law enforcement, but if they do report to law enforcement, it is often after a delay of days, weeks, months, or even years (please see Section 7 on difficulties in disclosure and delay in reporting).
…
7.4 The shock, shame, and stigma attached to being a victim of crime make it difficult for even adults to report victimization. It is not surprising that sexual assault has been found to be the most under-reported violent crime to any authority by adults and teenagers (Ciarlante, 2007). Victims often delay in reporting sexual victimization and face negative social reactions to disclosure (Dworkin et al., 2017; Fanflik, 2007). For children, there are additional factors that affect their willingness to disclose sexual abuse. …
[emphasis in original]
64 Ms Ng also explained in her report that the likelihood of delayed disclosure is greater in cases where the sexual assault was committed by an individual known to the victim. There could be a number of reasons for delayed disclosure by such victims, as Ms Ng explained:
7.7 Fear of vengeance and feelings of guilt and shame are the most important causes for suspending disclosure (Sauzier, 1989). Victims of intra-familial rape may have to continue to live in proximity with the perpetrator and hence fear punishment or retaliation if they disclose the assault. In the majority of cases, the absolute dominance of the offender upon the victim and the obedience of the latter, via complete submission and passivity, generate in the victim a feeling of “conspiracy” and complicity. Because the perpetrator’s strategies are oriented towards the maintenance of the child’s compliance and silence, the child is often inhibited to disclose abuse. As the child’s relationship with the perpetrator is often an emotionally significant one, many victims report ambivalent feelings for their perpetrators and do not disclose the abuse. Defining oneself as the victim of a family member’s assault requires significant and painful alterations in the victim’s perceptions of the perpetrator and the role that he/she was expected to demonstrate …
7.8 Victims of intra-familial assault often have a personal, financial, legal, or social relationship with their abusers that may make them dependent on their abusers. Family or social considerations such as loyalty to family members, wanting to protect the privacy of the family, fear of not being believed, fear of causing family disruption or bringing shame to the family, not [wanting] negative consequences for loved ones when they disclose etc. have a strong impact on the victim’s decision on whether to disclose the offence and how the disclosure is made. Some of these themes are consistent with local researchers’ views that when there is a relationship between the rape victim and the offender, the victim is more likely to experience a sense of betrayal and may come under suspicion or criticism about whether she had consented to having sexual intercourse with the perpetrator (Lim, Chan, Chan et al.,2002). …
65 We accept that a victim of sexual assault, especially a youthful one assaulted in a familial context, may not report the offence in a timely manner as there are empirically-supported psychological reasons for delayed reporting, including feelings of shame and fear. With respect, we must reject the Judge’s suggestion (see [40]–[41] of the GD) that with the passage of time, a victim would have recovered from distress or embarrassment and would have no difficulty in disclosing the offences and recounting the abuse that he or she was subjected to.
66 Therefore, that there is a delay in reporting by a complainant is not, on its own, reason to disbelieve the complainant and his or her allegations against an accused person. In this regard, we affirm the legal principles set out in past cases on how delay in reporting by a complainant should be treated by a court. These principles, in our view, give due regard to the likely thought-processes and behaviour of sexual assault victims as highlighted above.
67 In DT v Public Prosecutor [2001] 2 SLR(R) 583, the High Court stated (at [62]) that there is no general rule requiring victims of sexual offences to report the offences to the police immediately. The court explained that, instead, the explanations proffered by the complainant for his or her delay in reporting the offences to the police are to be considered by the court in determining the impact of the delay, if any, on the credibility of the complainant. We would add that the requirement of examining the reasons proffered by the complainant applies not only to the complainant’s delay in reporting the offences to the police, but also to any delay in disclosing the assault to anyone else, such as to his or her family members.
68 The above principles on the significance of delayed reporting by victims of sexual offences were also adopted by the High Court in the recent case of Public Prosecutor v Yue Roger Jr [2019] 3 SLR 749 (“Roger Yue (HC)”), which was a decision that we affirmed on appeal in Yue Roger Jr v Public Prosecutor [2019] 1 SLR 829. In Roger Yue (HC), Aedit Abdullah J found that the complainant’s failure to report the offences until five years later did not make her evidence less credible as there were reasonable explanations provided for her conduct. Aedit Abdullah J stated (at [30]):
I accepted that victims of sexual offences may not behave in a stereotypical way. Many victims report their sexual abuse early to a family member, friend, the police, or other person in authority. However, there is no general rule requiring victims of sexual offences to report the offences immediately or in a timely fashion. Instead, the explanation for any such delay in reporting is to be considered and assessed by the court on a case-by-case basis (see DT v PP [2001] 2 SLR(R) 583 at [62]; Tang Kin Seng v PP [1996] 3 SLR(R) 444 at [79]). While I accept that an omission to report the offence in a timely fashion, in the absence of other evidence, may in certain circumstances make it difficult to establish a case against the accused beyond reasonable doubt, I emphasise that the effect of any delay in reporting always falls to be assessed on the specific facts of each individual case.
We endorse the learned judge’s remarks in Roger Yue (HC).
69 Having assessed the evidence given by the complainant, we are satisfied that if we were to accept her primary allegations against the respondent, then there were plausible legitimate explanations for the complainant’s initial non-disclosure of the offences. Three reasons for the complainant’s initial non-disclosure of the offences can be discerned from her testimony.
70 First, she was afraid of the respondent. She testified that she had been warned multiple times by the respondent not to speak to anyone about the acts. The respondent had also allegedly told her about how he had previously participated in a gang-rape, and the complainant was fearful that she would be subjected to the same treatment should she disobey the respondent’s instructions to remain silent.
71 Second, the complainant explained that she had not disclosed the offences earlier to her family members as she did not want to spoil the relationship between the respondent and her mother, especially since the respondent (who she treated as a father figure) had promised to marry her mother. She also did not want to disclose the matter to the brother as she feared that he might do something untoward to the respondent as he was, according to her, a “very hot-tempered person”.
72 Third, the complainant explained that she was reluctant to lodge a police report as she was concerned over what she might have to go through at the trial, if the offences were reported.
73 We are satisfied that in this case, the delay in the complainant’s disclosure and her reluctance to report the matter to the police were based on reasons that were sound and credible from her perspective, and were in fact aligned with the expert evidence on the thought-processes and behaviour of many victims of sexual offences. Therefore, we find that the complainant’s delayed disclosure to her loved ones and her reluctance to make a police report, did not, taken in isolation, undermine her credibility.”
Leave a Reply