A student asked about ss 16-17 of the Supreme Court of Judicature Act 1969, which state what the civil jurisdiction of the General Division of the High Court encompasses. But doesn’t Hinds v R mean that that court, by definition, has “unlimited original jurisdiction” in “substantial” civil cases (which, it is submitted, must mean all civil cases not covered by the jurisdiction of a subordinate court)?
I understand section 16 of the SCJA to relate merely to the manner in which the jurisdiction of the High Court is to be invoked, rather than the subject-matter of the jurisdiction. (Similarly, I understand the purpose of s 15 to be to expand the range of situations in which the High Court has criminal jurisdiction beyond what is provided for at common law, as, for example, in the case of limb (e).)
As for section 17, I think one possibility is that it expands the jurisdiction of the High Court beyond what it has at common law, or at least clarifies doubts about the extent of its jurisdiction. (For an example of such doubts: The “Ocean Jade” [1991] 1 SLR(R) 354 (HC); Leong Wai Kum, ‘The High Court’s Inherent Power to Grant Declarations of Marital Status’ [1991] SJLS 13.)
Certain limbs of s 17 may also be necessary to expand the jurisdiction of the High Court beyond what an originalist reading of Art 93 would give the High Court (see e.g. Emilia Shipping Inc v State Enterprise for Pulp and Paper Industries [1991] 1 SLR(R) 411 (HC)).
While I am not entirely well-versed in the history of our courts, I note that courts in the Straits Settlements were created by the Second Charter of Justice in 1826 and restructured by the Straits Settlements Courts Ordinance in 1866 (an extract of which is reproduced on page 32 of Leong’s article). I understand that the latter gave the Supreme Court of the Straits Settlements the jurisdiction of the Court of Queen’s Bench, the Court of Chancery, the Court of Common Pleas, and the Court of Exchequer. This was before those four courts and others (e.g. the High Court of Admiralty) were combined into the High Court of England and Wales by the Judicature Acts, 1873-1875. Given this vintage, it is therefore possible that Malaysia’s Courts of Judicature Act 1964 (from which our SCJA was copied) was enacted in order to update the jurisdiction of the superior courts from what they had been fixed at as of 1866.
But all this is my tentative view only; I will need to do more research to verify its accuracy.
All that said, I must stress that, though the legislature has the power to pass laws conferring jurisdiction/power on the Supreme Court, the separation of powers still has the important consequence that the court exercises this jurisdiction/power without interference of the other branches of the state. Moreover, I do not think that it is open to the legislature to pass a law reducing the jurisdiction/powers of the Supreme Court/its components below what is required by the very labels “Supreme Court”, “High Court”, etc. in the Constitution [edit: this minimum ‘level’ includes the power to engage in judicial review of legislation and executive action]. For a Malaysian case where the legislature attempted to do this (by constitutional amendment no less) and failed, see the judgment of the Federal Court in Semenyih Jaya.
Leave a Reply