Benjamin Ong's notes

Notes about Singapore public law, etc. for my students (and possibly others)

Feedback on students’ presentation: Is there a better way for judges in Singapore to be appointed?

In general, the problem with choosing judges is that whoever has the power to choose may choose someone like them, and so perpetuate his mentality. One way to reduce this problem is to reduce the extent to which that “mentality” can play a role in the judge’s decision-making. The more unambiguous the laws which the judge has to apply, and the less power the judge has to change the law, the less likely it is that the judge can decide cases in line with a certain ideology/agenda/mentality instead of in accordance with law.

The group is to be commended for its sensitivity to the need to select appropriate comparative case studies (as opposed to, say, picking three countries at random to compare with Singapore). When addressing the question of whether there is a “better way” for Singapore, it is useful to consider (a) the extent to which the status quo in Singapore falls short; (b) possible alternatives; (c) whether those alternatives can be adopted in Singapore; (d) whether, if adopted, those alternatives will bring about an improvement. The group did well in describing the alternatives, their merits, and the feasibility of adopting them; more could have been said on their merits relative to the status quo. In describing the status quo, it would have been useful to distinguish between (a) problems that could arise; (b) whether those problems do arise.

More space for analysis could have been created by organising the presentation in a different manner. Instead of:

  1. Country A
    1. Describe its system
    2. Evaluate its system
    3. Can/should Singapore adopt its system?
  2. Country B
    1. Describe its system
    2. Evaluate its system
    3. Can/should Singapore adopt its system?
  3. Country C
    1. Describe its system
    2. Evaluate its system
    3. Can/should Singapore adopt its system?

the following might have been more efficient:

  1. Issue 1: who qualifies to be a judge?
    1. Status quo in Singapore
    2. Possibilities from Countries A, B, C…
    3. Can/should Singapore change?
  2. Issue 2: who shortlists potential judges?
    1. Status quo in Singapore
    2. Possibilities from Countries A, B, C…
    3. Can/should Singapore change?
  3. Issue 3: who makes the final choice?
    1. Status quo in Singapore
    2. Possibilities from Countries A, B, C…
    3. Can/should Singapore change?

The advantage of the latter scheme is that, by going feature-by-feature rather than country-by-country, it allows for an argument that Singapore should pick some features from country A, some from country C, etc. to be made more clearly and in fewer words.

Had time permitted, it could have been useful to distinguish between different types of judge. While all judges should have certain characteristics, e.g. independence, different types of judge may face different threats to these characteristics, or the level of importance of these characteristics may differ depending on the type of judge. For example, one argument for judicial security of tenure is that, otherwise, if X has the power to appoint judges then X could threaten a judge into ruling in X’s favour by threatening not to renew X’s appointment. But this threat would not work if that judge does not hear cases involving X in the first place.

It may also be useful to consider relationships between different types of judge. If judge A faces certain threats to his independence, but there is a right of appeal against judge A’s decisions to judge B, and judge B does not face such threats, then on the whole the judicial system does not suffer from such threats.

Some links to sources we mentioned in passing, for those who are interested:

  1. The UK Judiciary’s YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCi3XytDJY8a3I9_vL7A_5SQ – consider how the judiciary presents itself to the public.
  2. Gary Low, ‘Emphatic Plea for the Empathic Judge’ (2018) 30 Singapore Academy of Law Journal 97 <https://journalsonline.academypublishing.org.sg/Journals/Singapore-Academy-of-Law-Journal/e-Archive/ctl/eFirstSALPDFJournalView/mid/495/ArticleId/1260/Citation/JournalsOnlinePDF>.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *