The topic took the form ‘Because A is true, therefore B is true’. In response, one can ask, among others, questions like the following:
- Is A true?
- Is B true?
- Is there a causal link between A and B?
- Would B be true (or false) even if A were false (or true)?
What was said in the presentation was mostly correct. What could have been improved was bringing democracy into the discussion of judicial review, and explaining how everything that was said contributed to addressing the topic. For instance, what was said about the ultra vires theory of judicial review could have been augmented by stating the implications for democracy, e.g., the ultra vires theory may be more palatable to those who see lawmaking by a democratically elected legislature as the preferred means of lawmaking because, according to this theory, all judicial review is is the act of applying the rules made by the democratically-elected legislature – it is not the courts, which are not democratically elected, making up rules.
The presentation described how various constitutional provisions reflect certain democratic values. To complete the argument, it would be good to have said more on the extent to which judicial review ought to be the means by which those values are upheld. After all, other bodies are also charged with upholding those values, both in and of themselves and as reflected in the Constitution. Consider, for instance, the fact that MPs must take an oath saying that they will “preserve, protect and defend the Constitution of the Republic of Singapore” (see the First Schedule to the Constitution).
The presentation touched on various aspects of democracy – voting; democratic values; popular participation in decision-making. This could have been made more explicit. The presentation described a lot; ideally, the relevance of each fact to the topic (for example, one may ask: what does justiciability have to do with democracy? What is the relevance of Thio Li-ann’s proposed approach to judicial review?) would have been discussed in more detail.
As for the rule of law and the separation of powers, more could have been said on how these follow from democracy. If there is no necessary connection between these and democracy, then saying that judicial review upholds the rule of law/the separation of powers doesn’t quite address the question of how judicial review sits with democracy. If there is a necessary connection, this should be explained explicitly. Consider also: can there be a society with democracy but no judicial review (as Jeremy Waldron arguably envisages, at least under certain conditions: see the article referred to below)?
For further reading, consider Aileen Kavanagh, ‘Participation and Judicial Review: A Reply to Jeremy Waldron’ (2003) 22 Law and Philosophy 451 <https://www.jstor.org.libproxy.smu.edu.sg/stable/3505148>. (Note that she and Waldron are focusing on judicial review of legislation on the ground of unconstitutionality.)
Leave a Reply