Benjamin Ong's notes

Notes about Singapore public law, etc. for my students (and possibly others)

Feedback on a student presentation about juries

It is often said that juries are independent, etc. But so are judges. There are also threats to juries’ independence, but again the same can be said of judges. Juries cost public money, but so do judges. Perhaps, then, we should not ask whether a jury system would be good, but rather whether it would be better than the status quo.

What about playing on juries’ susceptibilities to particular modes of persuasion? Judges are human too, and it may well be that different types of argument or different methods of presenting a point may appeal to different judges. One may respond that judges are duty-bound to be wary of being bamboozled, but so are juries. Perhaps the difference is that judges get specialised training – which brings to mind [one team of students’] idea that there could be training for jurors.

[On students’ argument that juries can “temper justice with mercy”:] How? If the answer is that juries are supposed to render a fair decision, so do judges. If the answer is that the accused person is tried by more than one person, well, that could be addressed by having cases heard by panels of judges rather than a single judge. Some may argue that judges retain the power to acquit someone even if they believe the person is guilty – this is known as “jury nullification”, and is controversial because it is, in essence, an act of disobedience to the law. Moreover, where there is a range of possible sentences, there is already room for “mercy” in the selection of a sentence from that range.

Both teams pointed out that juries’ decisions as to guilt may be influenced by the possible sentence. That is true, but as a counterpoint, I would point out that judges have also said things like “There is no question that as a modality of punishment, capital punishment is different because of its irreversibility. For this reason, capital cases deserve the most anxious and searching scrutiny.” (Kho Jabing v PP [2016] 3 SLR 135 at [50]) and “A capital charge carries the ultimate penalty for an accused person and the court’s scrutiny in respect of this must not only be rigorous, but punctilious and searching.” (Imran bin Mohd Arip v PP [2021] SGCA 91 at [86]) This is not to say that the courts decide whether to find someone guilty based on the sentence that would be imposed in the even that they do; the point is simply that courts are mindful of the need to take extra care when someone’s life is on the line.

Both teams discussed the possibility that there is no impetus for the jury system to be re-introduced: there is no public pressure, etc. That is not a reason not to bring back the jury system; rather, it is the absence of a reason to bring back the jury system. While we’re on the topic, there is a lesson here. You could categorise some of the arguments into, for example, ‘push’ and ‘pull’ factors: there is a difference between a reason that the status quo is unsatisfactory, and a reason why the solution is the jury system (instead of something else).

Both teams could have said a bit more about was the role of judges in a jury system. […] If there were more time, both teams could also have considered issues such as whether a judge can/should be able to overrule the jury’s decision.

Note that one feature of jury systems is that juries’ deliberations are secret, which means that you can’t find out what the jury’s reasoning process is. Contrast this with judges, who are duty-bound not only to make a decision but also to state the reasons for their decision.

On what grounds can one appeal against a decision reached by a jury? It’s not as simple as saying that the jury misappreciated the evidence, gave undue weight to one piece of evidence, etc. This is simply because it’s not possible to know what the jury’s precise reasoning was! Therefore, in general, one can only succeed on an appeal if (a) the decision of the jury is so perverse that, in the face of the evidence, no reasonable jury could possibly have reached that decision; or (b) the judge had misdirected the jury as to what the law is. Note that different legal systems could conceivably have different rules on when one can appeal.

I briefly shared some thoughts about other possibilities. For example, one can imagine a court consisting of a panel of trained laypersons – like Magistrate’s Courts in the UK. Or there are courts which consist of a combination of professional judges and laypersons, as in Japan.

It’s hard to design legal institutions, isn’t it? One last thought: If a system is flawed, it could be because the design is flawed, or because the way in which it is implemented is flawed. By bearing in mind this distinction, we can better evaluate criticisms of the system. For example, consider the argument that jurors might not do a good job because they don’t want to be there. There could be two ways to address that problem: (a) get rid of the jury system altogether; (b) make jury service voluntary. Neither is perfect, but my point is that we shouldn’t forget to consider the second option.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *