In class, I mentioned that the Tan Seng Kee case was brought at least in part because of a comment by Tommy Koh on Facebook. I, for one, find it interesting that, in the world in which we live nowadays, comments on social media can not only be newsworthy, but also play a role in legal and political developments. I promised to substantiate these observations with facts, so here you go:
- On 6 September 2018, the Supreme Court of India handed down its judgment in Navtej Singh Johar v Union of India AIR 2018 SC 4321, in which it held that s 377 of the Indian Penal Code (“Whoever voluntarily has carnal intercourse against the order of nature with any man, woman or animal, shall be punished with imprisonment for life, or with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to ten years, and shall also be liable to fine.”) was unconstitutional “in so far as it criminalises consensual sexual conduct between adults of the same sex” (at [156(i)]). (The court’s reasoning is, in my view, largely inapplicable in Singapore.)
- The same day, Professor Simon Chesterman, who was (and still is) the Dean of the Faculty of Law at NUS, put up a Facebook post about the case.
- The same day, Professor Tommy Koh commented on the post: “I would encourage our gay community to bring a class action to challenge the constitutionality of Section 377A”.
- The same day, one Edward Tay replied: “Prof, hasn’t that angle been disposed of by Lim Meng Suang?”, referring to Lim Meng Suang v Attorney-General [2015] 1 SLR 26, in which Singapore’s Court of Appeal held that s 377A of Singapore’s Penal Code (“Any male person who, in public or private, commits, or abets the commission of, or procures or attempts to procure the commission by any male person of, any act of gross indecency with another male person, shall be punished with imprisonment for a term which may extend to 2 years.”) did not violate Art 9(1) or Art 12 of Singapore’s Constitution.
- The same day, Prof Koh replied: “try again”.
- On 10 September 2018, Mr Ong Ming Johnson (also known as DJ Big Kid) applied to the High Court for a declaration that s 377A violates Art 9(1), Art 12(1), and Art 14(1)(a) of the Constitution. On 12 September 2018, he told media that he had been “energised” by the decision of the Indian Supreme Court and decided to “take up” Prof Koh’s “challenge”.
- On or before 22 November 2018, Mr Choong Chee Hong (also known as Mr Bryan Choong) made a similar application to the High Court.
- On 21 September 2019, Dr Tan Seng Kee (also known as Dr Roy Tan) made a similar application to the High Court.
- On 30 March 2020, the High Court dismissed all three applications.
- The applicants appealed to the Court of Appeal. On 28 February 2022, the Court of Appeal declined to rule on the applications because it ordered that s 377A be “unenforceable in its entirety” (at [149]; emphasis removed). However, it made certain obiter remarks strongly suggesting that s 377A is unconstitutional. So, as Assoc Prof Eugene Tan later put it, s 377A is “on its last legs” and is in effect a “dead law“.
- On 21 August 2022, the Prime Minister announced during his National Day Rally speech that s 377A would be repealed for various reasons, including that “there is a significant risk of s377A being struck down, on the grounds that it breaches the Equal Protection provision in the Constitution”. He also announced that the Constitution would be amended so as to prevent the existing “definition of marriage [from being] challenged on constitutional grounds in the courts”. We currently await the text of the constitutional amendment. If it is passed, then it is not implausible that, sooner or later, the courts will have the occasion to rule on the precise effect of that amendment.
The decision in Navtej Singh Johar was irrelevant to the decisions of the Singapore courts, as were Prof Chesterman’s Facebook post and Prof Koh’s comments. Nonetheless, it is interesting to observe the effect that these developments have had on where we are today.
Leave a Reply