Benjamin Ong's notes

Notes about Singapore public law, etc. for my students (and possibly others)

An interesting case involving burning an entire row of houses

I might have mentioned the following case in class: Beaulieu v Finglam (1401) YB Pas 2 Hen IV, fo 18, pl 6, translated and reported in John Baker, Baker and Milsom: Sources of English Legal History (2nd ed, OUP, 2010) at 610-611.

In that case, which was heard by the Court of Common Pleas, it appears that an employee or a guest of Roger Finglam negligently caused a fire to spread to an entire row of houses.

Justice Markham stated the law as follows: “A man is bound to answer for his servant’s act, as for his lodger’s act, in such a case. For if my servant or lodger puts a candle on a wall and the candle falls into the straw and burns the whole house, and also my neighbour’s house, in this case I shall answer to my neighbour for the damage which he has suffered.”

Counsel then submitted: “This defendant will be undone and impoverished for ever if this action is maintainable against him, for then 20 other suits will be brought against him for the same matter.”

Chief Justice Thirning retorted: “What is that to us? It is better that he should be utterly undone than that the law should be changed for him.”

I can’t remember what point I was trying to make, but I have never forgotten this case since I first read it.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *