If your argument is that the act of prosecuting you is Wednesbury unreasonable because (for example) the evidence against you is so scanty that no reasonable prosecutor would prosecute you, the court will probably expect you to go through the trial first. In Patnaik, the court said just that at para 37.
But it’s interesting to me that the court said that only at para 37 (at the start of the part of the judgment dealing with the alleged irrationality), and not anywhere in the part of the judgment dealing with the alleged breach of Art 12.
So my sense is that the position is this:
- If your argument is that the very act of prosecuting you will be a breach of your constitutional rights, and you have enough evidence to show that it will be such a breach, I think you won’t be expected to go through the trial as an alternative remedy.
- If your argument isn’t about constitutional rights, but some other ground (such as illegality/irrationality):
- If your argument is fundamentally based on the PP’s evidence (for example, alleged error of fact by the PP, or allegedly no reasonable prosecutor would prosecute based on the evidence that you think the PP has), then you will be expected to go through the trial as an alternative remedy – for the reasons set out in Patnaik at [37]-[39].
- If not, good question – we don’t know yet. I would be inclined to think that you shouldn’t be expected to go through the trial. If, for example, you are being prosecuted in bad faith, there should be no reason to drag you through the process. This is unlike when you are alleging that the prosecution is Wednesbury unreasonable given the evidence, because the very point of the trial is that it’s a process to gather evidence, and a feature of criminal proceedings is that the Prosecution doesn’t have to tell you what evidence it has before it goes to trial.
- That leaves us with a difficult question: what if your argument is that the prosecution is bound to fail because, even assuming the facts alleged in the charge are true, they can’t possibly amount to the offence you’re charged with? I don’t know off the top of my head, and you don’t need to know this for the exam – a criminal procedure textbook will tell you the answer.
Leave a Reply