Benjamin Ong's notes

Notes about Singapore public law, etc. for my students (and possibly others)

Congressional hearings in the US – what’s the equivalent in Singapore? And why are there fewer/less active select committees in Singapore compared to, say, the UK?

Why are there so many congressional hearings in the US, and why are select committees in Singapore, by contrast, not so active?

It’s not just because the US has a Presidential rather than Parliamentary system of governance. There are Westminster-style systems (like the UK itself) where we see more and more active parliamentary select committees than in Singapore; and because it is (usually) Congress itself that decides what hearings to hold, Congress could in theory hold far fewer hearings than it does. (Are there are many congressional hearings in, say, the Philippines – or other presidential systems – as in the US? Or fewer, or maybe even more?)

One determinant might be the size of the US, and hence the number of matters that Congress sees fit to deal with; I don’t feel qualified to comment further. That said, I have a hunch that the most important feature is the ruling party’s preferred style of governance. 

In Singapore, because it is Parliament that gets to decide by motion whether to appoint a select committee (Standing Orders of Parliament, SO 101), the ruling party has the power to block any opposition party’s attempt to convene a select committee. In theory, backbenchers from the ruling party could do this, but the fact that they have not may indicate that they either do not have the inclination or that they are whipped into not doing so. Yet, I believe that the position is similar in the US, which would mean that the differences don’t relate to differences in the systems of governance, but rather the culture of governance. I also understand that party whips are less strict in political parties in the US than in Singapore; this too could be relevant.

What is the closest functional equivalent of congressional hearings in Singapore? We know that the government holds closed-door consultation sessions on bills (my colleagues and I have been to a few of these) as well as on other issues. There are also public consultations on various general issues (including proposed bills) as well as more specific matters; these generally do not take place orally, but they are consultations nonetheless. These may well be Singapore’s equivalent of congressional hearings. They do not necessarily take place orally, but there is nothing magic about an oral hearing; indeed, certain pieces of information may well be easier to communicate in writing, and besides, some closed-door hearings do take place orally, while there are witnesses who give written but not oral evidence to Parliamentary select committees (and perhaps to Congressional hearings too?) They are not necessarily open to the public, but then again, in the US, there is nothing to stop senators/representatives from meeting people and getting their views behind closed doors too. Perhaps the differences are more apparent than real; perhaps it is a question of labelling and the degree of publicity.

It may also be worth noting that MPs who are not members of the ruling party are at liberty to conduct consultations in the loose sense of getting people’s views. This could take the form of a petition to Parliament, which will then be considered by the Public Petitions Committee (a standing select committee of Parliament).

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *