In class, I said something about the story of Adam and Eve. I express no opinion here on the theological significance, if any, of that story. I was instead referring from the following statement from R v Chancellor, Masters and Scholars of the University of Cambridge (Dr Bentley’s Case) (1723) 1 Stra 557 at 567; 93 ER 698 at 704. The University of Cambridge had stripped Dr Bentley of his degrees, but in a procedurally flawed manner. Among other things, he had not been given a fair hearing. Fortescue J said:
“The laws of God and man both give the party an opportunity to make his defence, if he has any. I remember to have heard it observed by a very learned man upon such an occasion, that even God himself did not pass sentence upon Adam, before he was called upon to make his defence. Adam (says God) where art thou? Hast thou not eaten of the tree, whereof I commanded thee that thou shouldst not eat? And the same question was put to Eve also.”
There are at least two interesting glosses on this view. First, as Lord Hoffmann pointed out in SSHD v AF (No 3) [2010] 2 AC 269 at [72], here there was no cost to the public interest of granting a fair hearing: “God suffered no disadvantage by revealing to Adam what he knew.”; fairness may require something different if, for example, disclosing to someone certain details of the case against them would be contrary to the public interest.
Second, as Lord Reed pointed out in R (Osborn) v Parole Board [2014] AC 1115 at [69], “Adam was allowed a hearing notwithstanding that God, being omniscient, did not require to hear him in order to improve the quality of His decision-making”. Lord Reed was emphasising a quite different point from Lord Hoffmann: his point was that a fair hearing is not just a means to the end of a substantively sound decision; a fair hearing has an intrinsic dignitarian value (see also [70] of his judgment).
Leave a Reply