Benjamin Ong's notes

Notes about Singapore public law, etc. for my students (and possibly others)

Income-based fines

Some students asked for my views about income-based fines, which were discussed in the StraitsTimes Forum some time ago.

To my mind, Ms Sim Joo Geok’s argument against income-based fines misses the mark. Sim appeals to the idea of equality. But that idea calls to mind a fundamental question (which one would learn about if one studies discrimination law): does equality demand that people face the same treatment, or that people face the same impact? She assumes it is the former. But the law appears to contemplate the latter: see M Raveendran v PP [2021] SGHC 254 at [15]; see also Syed Suhail bin Syed Zin v AG [2021] SGHC 274 at [61].

Now, it is true that the court in M Raveendran argued that this reasoning should not apply to circumstances “extrinsic” to the offender, such as income. But the reasons for the court’s view were ones of pragmatism, not principle: see [32]-[35].

I also cannot agree with Ms Sim’s analogy with incarceration. A $10 hits the person who earns $100 harder than the person who earns $1,000. But a 1-year jail sentence arguably hits both equally, insofar as we can assume that the two persons have roughly the same lifespan.

To my mind, the best arguments against income-based fines are indeed pragmatic ones. There could be problems defining ‘income’ fairly: do we consider employment income only, or only investment income? There may, after all, be super-rich people who earn income only from investment. But – unlike with employment income (as regards which, the court could simply ask to see the offender’s tax returns, or even get them directly from IRAS) – there is no official national database of people’s investments. One may ask whether it would be fairer to use wealth rather than income as a measure. But, again, it would be difficult to measure the amount of wealth that people have.

I cannot disagree with Mr Rahul Patwardhan’s other suggestions, nor with Mr Edward Eng’s more considered views, particularly that “[w]e cannot let perfection[ism] get in the way of improvement”.

See also the debates in Parliament on 8 July 2019. Mr Walter Theseira discussed income- and wealth-based fines. Ms Sun Xueling said the government would not rule that out.

If two persons who are otherwise similarly situated are to be sentenced to caning, should the one with less sensitive nerve endings on his buttocks be sentenced to more strokes of the cane?

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *