Benjamin Ong's notes

Notes about Singapore public law, etc. for my students (and possibly others)

Prizes in arcades

(For the avoidance of doubt, the following isn’t legal advice.)

What is the legal basis for the new rule [introduced in 2024] that prizes at arcades can be worth only $100 or less?

The starting point is s 18 of the Gambling Control Act 2022 states that one needs a licence to “conduct gaming”. That includes “mak[ing] available to others, any gaming machine for the purpose of gambling”. It would appear, from the definitions in s 3, that any arcade gaming machine would count as a “gaming machine” if it is a “game of chance” and there are prizes to be won – that is, unless it is an “amusement machine”. To be an “amusement machine”, the machine must, among other things, give no prize, or provide a prize (per game) which is “less than $100”.

So the starting point is that one needs a licence to operate arcade machines that allow players to play a game of chance and win a prize that is worth $100 or more.

The Gambling Control (High-Value Amusement Machines – Exemption) Order 2023, however, created an exception to this. It stated that if one has (among other things) a public entertainment licence, one does not need a gambling licence to operate a “high-value amusement machine”, which is basically an arcade machine where one can win a prize that is worth $100 or more.

The Order was revoked with effect from 1 March 2024.

In theory, an arcade operator could still apply for a licence to “conduct gaming”, which would encompass providing machines allowing players to play a “game of chance” and win a prize worth more than $100. So we can see MHA’s announcement as a statement that, as a matter of policy, no such licences will be granted to arcades.

Some of you also asked whether players who had earned coupons etc. before 1 March 2024 could exchange the coupons after 1 March 2024 for prizes worth more than $100. I believe the law does not forbid this. What the Act states is that one requires a licence to “conduct gaming”, which includes making available arcade machines from which one can win a prize. I would say that if someone won $200 worth of coupons on (say) 1 February 2024, the prize would be won then – the prize would simply be a contractual right to exchange the coupons for $200 worth of prizes. Accordingly, no offence would be committed if this contractual right were exercised after 1 March 2024, because the right would already have accrued – “won” – before that.

If I am right, it would follow that arcade operators were not legally obliged to require that tickets won before 1 March 2024 can only be redeemed for prizes worth less than $100. They were of course at liberty to do this, subject to the terms of the contracts they had with the players. Perhaps the potential practical problem was that tickets didn’t have dates on them.

Come to think of it, this would be an interesting contract law exam question.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *