Benjamin Ong's notes

Notes about Singapore public law, etc. for my students (and possibly others)

The Presidential Council for Minority Rights and Article 12 of the Constitution

If the PCMR issues an adverse report on a Bill, but Parliament passes it anyway, would it nonetheless be unconstitutional for violating Art 12?

Not necessarily. The test applied by the PCMR is different from the test applied by the courts under Art 12.

The PCMR’s job is to identify “differentiating measures”. Art 68 says a “differentiating measure” is “any measure which is, or is likely in its practical application to be, disadvantageous to persons of any racial or religious community and not equally disadvantageous to persons of other such communities, either directly by prejudicing persons of that community or indirectly by giving advantage to persons of another community”. At the risk of over-simplifying: once there’s unequal treatment, there’s a differentiating measure.

But that is not the test under Art 12. The Art 12 tests for legislation and executive action, broadly speaking, don’t forbid unequal treatment – they allow it under some circumstances if (broadly speaking) it is justified. By contrast, the test applied by the PCMR doesn’t account for the possibility that there is differential treatment but it is justified.

That being so, the fact that Parliament has okayed the Bill despite the adverse report is irrelevant.

If the PCMR doesn’t issue an adverse report on a Bill, will the courts presume that it doesn’t violate Art 12?

No. The PCMR doesn’t have the authoritative word on the interpretation/application of the Constitution – so an Act on which the PCMR hasn’t issued an adverse report can’t be presumed constitutionally valid: see Ravi s/o Madasamy v AG [2017] 5 SLR 489 at [87]. Indeed, the court said at [88] that it agreed with the PCMR, meaning that the court carried out an independent assessment; the court did not stop at saying that it presumed that the PCMR was right, and explicitly said that it’s not bound by what the PCMR says (and, for good measure, that – as I said above – the PCMR’s test is different from the Art 12 test). At most the court might defer to the PCMR’s views, but – as always – the decision to defer is a considered decision, not a mere presumption.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *