Benjamin Ong's notes

Notes about Singapore public law, etc. for my students (and possibly others)

The Fulham Corp case – who was Yapp? (More generally, who can apply for judicial review?)

Not everybody can apply for judicial review of just about anything. One must have standing (or locus standi, which literally means a “place to stand”) to apply for judicial review. Different legal systems have different tests for standing. In the UK, one must have “sufficient interest” in the matter complained of. In Singapore, the law is a bit more (over)complicated, but, in short, you must have been personally affected, or you must be in a category of people affected more than and/or differently from others. For example, only a man who had sex with men could apply for judicial review of s 377A of the Penal Code; similarly, “if there is a law which provides that it is an offence for any person of a particular race to take public buses”, only persons of that race will have standing to challenge that law (Tan Eng Hong v AG [2012] 4 SLR 476 (CA) [93]).

There is an exception: the Attorney-General has standing to apply for judicial review, which stems from the UK Attorney General’s “ancient power to make legal claims in the name of the Crown as an aspect of his role as guardian of the public interest” (De Smith’s Judicial Review, 8th ed, at [2-016]). (This power is not as illusory as it may appear. One would think that, in the UK, the AG would sometimes have a reason to apply for judicial review by something done by a local government authority.)

If you don’t have standing, what can you do? You can try to persuade the AG to apply for judicial review. Or you can ask the AG for permission – his fiat – to apply for judicial review in the AG’s name. The latter is called a “relator action” – we say that (as in the Fulham case) the action is brought by “the Attorney-General at the relation of Yapp”, and the case might be titled “AG ex rel Yapp v Fulham Corporation” (“ex rel” stands for “ex relatione”).

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *