Benjamin Ong's notes

Notes about Singapore public law, etc. for my students (and possibly others)

“I know it when I see it”

In Jacobellis v Ohio, Justice Potter Stewart said that, under the US Constitution, speech can only be banned on the ground that it is “obscene” if it is as devoid of social value as “hard core pornography”. Justice Stewart’s definition of “hard core pornography” was: “I know it when I see it”. I Googled the latter phrase and was sent down an interesting rabbit-hole. Then I found this paper by Paul Gewirtz. He notes the criticism that that phrase “seems to be based on a nonrational, intuitive gut reaction, instead of reasoned analysis” (1025). But he disagrees. He says that even if you can’t put into words what one ‘sees’, a legal test that relies on an emotional judgment is no less valid than a legal test phrased in the form of a checklist. In fact, he says, the “I know it when I see it” test is probably better than, say, a test that considers specifically “body parts shown, arousal, numbers of people, positions of bodies, and so forth” (at 1031).

I found what Gewirtz says about emotion an interesting foil to what Lord Carnwath says about words like “anxious”.

Is the phrase “I know it when I see it” similar to “so unreasonable that no reasonable person…”? (Thanks to a previous student for asking that question.) My initial response was that there is a difference. The phrase, “… that no reasonable person…”, tells us to what extent there is something, but it doesn’t tell us what that ‘something’ is: what does “unreasonable” mean? By contrast, the word “obscene” at least tells us what the ‘something’ is – namely, prurience. That said, I agree that if “I know it when I see it” can be a workable reasonable test, then so can “ew”, “ick”, or “so unreasonable that no reasonable person…”

Speaking of emotion: if you’re interested, check out this paper by Gary Low.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *