Benjamin Ong's notes

Notes about Singapore public law, etc. for my students (and possibly others)

The law on gambling

Gambling per se was never unlawful. What was unlawful (under the now-repealed Common Gaming Houses Act 1961) was “gaming” in a “common gaming house”, which meant “any place kept or used for gaming to which the public or any class of the public has or may have access, and any place kept for habitual gaming, whether the public or any class of the public has or may have access thereto or not, and any place kept or used for the purpose of a public lottery whether the public has access thereto or not”. “Gaming”, in turn, meant “the playing of any game of chance or of mixed chance and skill for money or money’s worth”. “Gaming” in public was also an offence.

(There were statutory exemptions for licensed casinos and gambling organised by the Tote Board.)

It was similarly unlawful under the Betting Act 1960 to bet in a “common betting house”.

One might think that it was not clear what “habitual” meant. If a group of friends met every week to play mahjong for money, wouldn’t that be “habitual gaming”? Then again, according to R v Fong Chong Cheng [1930] SSLR 139, “a place does not become a common gaming house merely because gaming habitually occurs in it. A private residence is not a common gaming house because the owner makes a practice of inviting his friends to it to gamble.” Rather, the law criminalised the “use of premises either for public gambling, or for the special purpose of a gambling saloon” (ibid), as well as the use of “the facade of a personal dwelling” to mask the fact that a place is “primarily kept for gaming” (PP v Yap Ah Yoon [1993] 1 SLR(R) 506).

That said, it may well be that the point of both Acts was never to target people gambling in private. This article gives us a hint about the sort of thing that the law aimed to target. I haven’t read about the matter in detail, but I was once curious and Googled various games on the list of games declared by the Minister to be “games of chance or mixed games of chance and skill”. It seems to me that point of that list was to make it harder for accused persons to argue that those games were somehow games of skill, and hence not “gaming”: for evidence, go to LawNet and search for “chap ji kee” OR “chap ji ki”.

The Gambling Control Act 2022 affirms that “social gambling” is not unlawful. For the reasons set out in the cases referred to above, I would not say that the Act legalised social gambling; indeed, the MHA’s position has been that such gambling was never illegal. If anything, the Act tightened the rules by restricting online social gambling, etc. (I cannot presently purport to provide a comprehensive overview of the Act.) I would like to highlight that something can be “social gambling” even if you’re gambling for money.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *