The case law now says yes: BOI v BOJ [2018] SGCA 61 at [107]-[110]. I don’t really see a contradiction between this and statements in other cases saying that prejudgment is simply a complete failure to exercise discretion. If you ask me, the various cases are speaking at cross-purposes. My view is that prejudgment is arguably not itself biased decision-making, but rather the failure to take into consideration what the parties have to say – which we might well call a failure to take into account relevant considerations. But the point made by BOI is that it is not only actual prejudgment, but also apparent prejudgment, that can render a decision unlawful. In other words, the standard of proof for prejudgment is the same as that for apparent bias, and that’s why the court said that prejudgment can itself amount to “apparent bias”. Either way, the question is what the “fair-minded, informed and reasonable observer” would think: see [109].
Leave a Reply