Benjamin Ong's notes

Notes about Singapore public law, etc. for my students (and possibly others)

When the Legislature amends the Constitution, should this be described as an exercise of “legislative power” or “constituent power”?

This is a hotly debatable question: see the summary of the debate in Yaniv Roznai, Unconstitutional Constitutional Amendments: The Limits of Amendment Powers (OUP, 2017) at 110-113. Roznai argues that the power to amend the constitution “should neither be regarded as another form of constituted power nor equated with the constituent power; it is a sui generis power” (113). He concludes at 133-134 that “the amendment power is a constitutional power delegated to a certain constitutional organ” (which, in Singapore, is the Legislature), and that this power is thereby limited by the scope of the grant of power by “the people”. At 121ff, he refers to this delegated power as “secondary constituent power”, which he distinguishes from the “primary constituent power” that vests in the people.

Perhaps this account can explain the nature of Singapore’s Legislature’s power to amend the Constitution. The Legislature is exercising what may be described as constituent power, but it is not the only sort of constituent power: it remains open to the people of Singapore to decide to tear up the existing Constitution and replace it with a new one. The exercise of such primary constituent power would, by definition, not be mentioned in the Constitution, because the existence of this power is logically anterior to the Constitution.

To my mind, the primary reason why amendments to the Constitution by the Legislature have legitimacy is that they are the product of a legal power created by the Constitution. On the other hand, a Constitution that is the result of the exercise of primary constituent power derives its legitimacy from the political fact of its acceptance by the People, rather than from a legal source.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *