Benjamin Ong's notes

Notes about Singapore public law, etc. for my students (and possibly others)

Legislation that purports to oust judicial review on some grounds but not others

I don’t think that the CA’s judgment in Nagaenthran only says that a statute that totally prevents the court from engaging in judicial review on any ground would be “constitutionally suspect”. At [43], the Court of Appeal noted that “the [PP’s] position is that aside from the grounds of bad faith, malice and unconstitutionality, the supervisory jurisdiction of the courts over the PP’s determination under s 33B(2)(b) of the MDA is excluded by s 33B(4)”. At [74], the Court of Appeal said that “[i]f the respondent’s submission on the effect of s 33B(4) were accepted, then to the extent that this ousted the court’s power of judicial review, s 33B(4) would be constitutionally suspect…” One could read this as saying that not only a complete ouster of judicial review, but even the notion that s 33B ousts judicial review on some grounds, would be “constitutionally suspect”.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *