Benjamin Ong's notes

Notes about Singapore public law, etc. for my students (and possibly others)

Collective ministerial responsibility

There isn’t much that has been written about collective ministerial responsibility in Singapore; there is much more in UK constitutional law textbooks, if you’re interested. As to the content of the principle, see this guide produced by the House of Commons Library, section II.A.

I would like to stress that, while the Singapore Constitution says that Cabinet is collectively responsible to Parliament, it does not prescribe any legal consequence for breach. That is by design. The principle of collective responsibility was inherited from the UK, where the principle is not a legal rule, but rather a non-legal convention. The consequences for breach – in both the UK and Singapore – are political, not legal. I can think of three possible consequences for a breach of the principle of collective responsibility:

  1. The electorate might, in response, vote the government out.
  2. Parliament might, in response, pass a motion that it has no confidence in the government. That might prompt the government to resign. The President will then have to appoint a new Prime Minister (Constitution, Art 25), or, if “there is no Member of Parliament likely to command the confidence of a majority of the Members thereof”, dissolve Parliament (Art 65(2)), in which case an election must be called (Art 66).
  3. Even without a Parliamentary motion of no confidence, the President may independently form the view that the Prime Minister has “ceased to command the confidence of a majority of the Members of Parliament” (Art 26(1)(b)). The President can then declare the office of PM vacant, in which case he will have to appoint a new PM (Art 25); or, “if the Prime Minister so requests, the President may dissolve Parliament instead of making such a declaration” (Art 26(1)(b)) – in which case, an election must be called (Art 66).

For more on the President’s power to dismiss the Prime Minister, see Seow Zhixiang, ‘Upholding Responsible Government: Legal and Political Controls on the Prorogation Power in Singapore’ [2020] SJLS 665, section VI.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *