The following is, of course, not legal advice.
- It is a criminal offence to possess “controlled drugs” for the “purpose of trafficking”: s 5(2). Here, to “traffic” means:
- “to sell, give, administer, transport, send, deliver or distribute” (s 2(1));
- while knowing the “specific nature of the drug” (e.g., that it is heroin): Adili Chibuike Ejike v PP [2019] SGCA 38, [35].
- If you have “possession”, “custody”, or “control” of “anything containing a controlled drug” (e.g. a box), “the keys of anything containing a controlled drug”, or “the keys of any place or premises or any part thereof in which a controlled drug is found”, you are presumed to have possession of the drug: s 18(1). Therefore, you can rebut this presumption by showing that, for example:
- You did not know that the thing containing the drug (e.g. the box) contained something (e.g. you thought that it was an empty box).
- You did not know that the thing/premises contained drugs; you thought it contained something else: Jumaat bin Mohamed Sayed v AG [2022] SGHC 291, [32], citing Obeng Comfort at [35].
- Note also that as a matter of law, you don’t “possess” something if you don’t even know that you have it. Hence, if you are found to have drugs in your bag, you are presumed to have possession of those drugs; but you can rebut this by showing, for example, “that the drug was slipped into [your] bag… without [your] knowledge”: Obeng Comfort at [35]. Another way to put this point is that you can rebut the presumption by showing that you thought the bag contained only (say) clothes, and not clothes plus drugs.
- However, you are considered to know something if you are wilfully blind to it – in other words, if you had a “clear, grounded and targeted suspicion”, and you had a reasonable means to check, yet you did not check: Adili at [94]. So for example, if you see someone slipping something into your bag and say “Here are some drugs”, the onus is on you to check what that thing was. Better yet, go straight to the police, tell them what happened, and let them check, so that your fingerprints don’t end up on that thing.
- If you are proved to possess a certain amount of drugs or above, you are presumed to have possessed the drugs for the purpose of trafficking: s 17.
- You can rebut this presumption by showing that, for example, you possessed the drugs for your own consumption. (It doesn’t count as trafficking if you are “administer[ing]” the drugs to yourself.) For this, you will need to show evidence of things such as your rate of drug consumption and ability to afford to buy drugs in such a large quantity just for your own consumption. This is sometimes called the “consumption defence”.
- You can also rebut this presumption by showing that you were holding the drugs on behalf of someone else, and the only purpose of holding the drugs was to return them to that person, and “the act of returning the drugs is not part of the process of supply or distribution of drugs”: Ramesh a/l Perumal v PP [2019] 1 SLR 1003 (CA) [114] (emphasis removed). This is sometimes called the “bailment defence”.
- If you are proven or presumed to possess a controlled drug, you are presumed to know the “nature of that drug”: s 18(2).
- You can rebut this presumption by showing that you “genuinely believed” that what you were carrying was “something innocuous” or that it was some other drug: Jumaat bin Mohamed Sayed v AG [2022] SGHC 291, [32], citing Masoud Rahimi bin Mehrzad v PP [2017] 1 SLR 257 (CA) [55].
- But it’s not enough merely to claim that you knew you were carrying something but you didn’t know what it was: Obeng Comfort v PP [2017] SGCA 12, [39].
- The court will also, of course, not necessarily accept your claim at face value. In Saravanan Chandaram v PP [2020] 2 SLR 95, the offender (who was carrying cannabis) claimed to have thought that he was carrying tobacco for a man named Aya. But the court rejected this claim, as he knew that Aya was a “drug syndicate leader”; “he had previously done jobs for Aya in connection with Aya’s drug deals; and he had been promised substantial monetary rewards for bringing the bundles in question into Singapore. In these circumstances, [the court] held that it was simply incredible that the appellant would have accepted at face value Aya’s alleged statement that the bundles only contained contraband tobacco”: Adili at [63].
- You can rebut this presumption by showing that you “genuinely believed” that what you were carrying was “something innocuous” or that it was some other drug: Jumaat bin Mohamed Sayed v AG [2022] SGHC 291, [32], citing Masoud Rahimi bin Mehrzad v PP [2017] 1 SLR 257 (CA) [55].
Leave a Reply