The victim of a crime has no standing to challenge the sentence imposed by the court, nor to challenge the PP’s decision not to appeal against the sentence: Huang Meizhe v Attorney-General [2011] 2 SLR(R) 1149 at [28]. I respectfully suggest that the reasoning in that case is not as clearly stated as in R v Nunn [1996] 2 Cr App R (S) 136 (EWCA) at 140 and R (Bulger) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2001] 3 All ER 449 (EWHC) at [19]-[23] (which cited Nunn). According to Nunn at 140:
“We mean no disrespect to the mother and sister of the deceased, but the opinions of the victim, or the surviving members of the family, about the appropriate level of sentence do not provide any sound basis for reassessing a sentence. If the victim feels utterly merciful towards the criminal, and some do, the crime has still been committed and must be punished as it deserves. If the victim is obsessed with vengeance, which can in reality only be assuaged by a very long sentence, as also happens, the punishment cannot be made longer by the court than would otherwise be appropriate. Otherwise cases with identical feature would be dealt with in widely differing ways leading to improper and unfair disparity, and even in this particular case, as the short judgment has already indicated, the views of the members of the family of the deceased are not absolutely identical.
If carried to its logical conclusion the process would end up by imposing unfair pressures on the victims of crime or the survivors of a crime resulting in death, to play a part in the sentencing process which many of them would find painful and distasteful. […]”
Bulger at [21] adds:
“If the family of a victim could challenge the sentencing process, why not the family of the defendant? Should the Official Solicitor be permitted to represent the interests of children adversely affected by the imprisonment of their mother? Should organisations representing victims or offenders be permitted to intervene? In my judgment, the answer in all these cases is that the Crown and the defendant are the only proper parties to criminal proceedings. A proper discharge of judicial functions in relation to sentencing requires that the judge take into account (as Lord Woolf CJ said he did in this case) the impact of the offence and the sentence on the public generally, and on individuals, including the victim and the victim’s family and the defendant and the defendant’s family. The nature of that impact is properly channelled through prosecution or defence.”
What, then, is the role of the victim in sentencing? See s 228 of the Criminal Procedure Code 2010, which provides that the prosecution may, in its sentencing submissions, refer to a “victim impact statement” – which means “any statement relating to any harm suffered by any person as a direct result of an offence, which includes physical bodily harm or psychological or psychiatric harm”. So if you are the victim of a crime and you wish to communicate your views about how the crime has affected you, get in touch with the prosecutor and ask to make a victim impact statement.
Leave a Reply